Route/trigger templates declared at a group now fan out to EVERY descendant
app in the DB subtree, not just the app nodes present in the current
`pic apply --dir`. A template change at group N reaches subtree(N) across
repos, and a removed/disabled template reaps its expansions on those
descendants too.
- group_repo: recursive `descendant_app_ids` (+ `_tx`) — inverse of the
ancestor chain CTE, app_id-ordered, depth-bounded.
- apply_service: Phase B2 expands templates into descendants of every in-tree
group not already handled in Phase B. All descendant locks are taken up
front in the single sorted batch (their union is invariant under reparenting
in-tree groups), so there is no out-of-order mid-tx locking / deadlock.
Per-recipient write caps (AppWriteRoute / AppManageTriggers /
AppSecretsRead-for-email) are required AUTHORITATIVELY IN-TX against the
post-reparent, already-locked app — checked set == written set, no TOCTOU.
expand_*_templates_tx are now self-contained (load hand-declared identities
from the tx), so collisions are caught on descendants too. Blast radius now
counts the true DB subtree. Descendant expansion errors are tagged with the
app slug (e.g. an {env} template on a NULL-environment descendant names it).
- apply_api: the pre-tx descendant authz pass is removed in favour of the
in-tx gate (sound via the hierarchy-aware effective_app_role).
- templates journey: out-of-tree descendant at depth 1 AND 2 receives the
expansion and is reaped on template removal.
- doc §4.5: strike the in-apply-only scope limitation.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Route/trigger template `{var:NAME}` placeholders now resolve against vars
applied in the SAME `pic apply` transaction, not committed-only state — so a
var and a template referencing it converge in one apply instead of two.
- config_resolver: add tx-scoped `fetch_var_candidates_tx`, sharing the SQL
tail (`VAR_CANDIDATES_TAIL`) with the pool variant so they can't drift.
- apply_service: `expand_route_templates_tx`/`expand_trigger_templates_tx`
read vars via the tx (vars are reconciled in Phase A / the app's own
reconcile, both before Phase B expansion).
- templates journey: `route_template_var_resolves_in_same_apply` — would fail
against the old committed-only read.
- doc §4.5: strike the `{var:NAME}` committed-only limitation.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Completes §4.5 templates (M4a shipped routes). A group declares a trigger once;
the tree apply fans it out into one concrete per-app_id trigger on each
descendant app, reusing the M4a expansion engine over the trigger insert path.
- Migration 0054: `trigger_templates` table (group-owned; the whole
BundleTrigger wire object stored as `spec` JSONB, placeholders unresolved) +
`triggers.from_template` provenance column + index.
- `template_repo.rs`: trigger-template CRUD + chain-load.
- Manifest: `[group]` `[[trigger_templates]]` (flat: name, kind, script, + kind
params); build_bundle emits them; rejected on an app node.
- Apply: group nodes reconcile trigger-template rows; tree Phase B expands each
chain trigger template into a concrete trigger per descendant app —
placeholders resolved in every spec string leaf, then the typed trigger is
rebuilt and inserted through the shared `insert_bundle_trigger_tx` (email
secrets resolved + re-sealed per recipient app). Idempotent via from_template
(one trigger per template per app; semantic-identity compare → no-op /
delete+recreate / reap). Collision with a hand-declared trigger or between
templates is a hard error. Each resolved trigger is re-validated with the
per-kind shape check (cron/queue/etc.) so a {var:}-injected bad
schedule/timeout can't slip in.
- Authz: declaring → GroupScriptsWrite; receiving → AppManageTriggers, plus
AppSecretsRead for email-trigger recipients (parity with hand-declared email).
- Plan/token/report extended for trigger templates; blast radius covers both.
- Tests: tests/templates.rs trigger fan-out (kv + {app_slug}, stable-ids,
prune-reap); resolve_placeholders_in_json unit test; schema golden reblessed.
Reviewed (no CRITICAL; isolation + per-app email-secret sealing verified
sound). Closed a HIGH validation-parity gap (re-validate resolved triggers) and
a MEDIUM authz gap (AppSecretsRead for email expansions). v1.2 Hierarchies
template work (M4) complete.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
§4.5 of the groups/project-tool design. A group declares a route ONCE; the
tree apply fans it out into one concrete per-app_id route on every descendant
app — instantiation, not inheritance (the cross-app isolation boundary is
unchanged; expanded rows stay app-owned).
- Migration 0053: `route_templates` table (group-owned) + `routes.from_template`
provenance column + index.
- `template_repo.rs`: tx-aware CRUD + chain-load (mirrors group_repo/route_repo).
- Manifest: `[group]` `[[route_templates]]`; build_bundle emits them; rejected
on an app node (422).
- Apply: group nodes reconcile template rows (create/update/delete via the
plan); tree Phase B expands each chain template into a concrete route per
descendant app node — placeholders {app_slug}/{env}/{var:NAME} resolved per
app (unknown var/placeholder = hard error), script bound nearest-owner-wins.
Idempotent via from_template (diffed create/update-as-replace/delete; re-apply
is no-churn, --prune reaps expansions). Collision with a hand-declared route,
or between two templates, is a hard error. Each RESOLVED expansion is
validated like a hand-declared route (reserved-path, path/host parse,
host-claim) so a {var:}-injected path or unclaimed strict host can't slip in.
- Plan: route-template diff at the group node + blast-radius (descendant app
count in this apply); state_token folds each template (edit trips StateMoved).
- Authz: declaring → GroupScriptsWrite; an app receiving expansions →
AppWriteRoute (gated even with no hand-declared routes).
- Tests: tests/templates.rs (fan-out + per-slug + idempotent-stable-ids +
prune-reap + collision-rejected); placeholder/validation unit tests; schema
golden reblessed.
Reviewed (no CRITICAL/HIGH; isolation core verified sound). Closed the two
validation-parity MEDIUMs (host-claim + reserved-path/pattern on expansions)
and added an out-of-apply-descendant prune warning. Scope: expansion targets
app nodes in the tree apply (not yet cross-repo descendants); {var:NAME} uses
committed vars. M4b (trigger templates) reuses this engine next.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
§7 of the groups/project-tool design. A group node is now authoritatively
managed by exactly one project-root; `pic apply --dir` claims, conflicts,
takes over, and (with --prune) structurally reaps owned nodes.
- Migration 0052: `projects(id, key UNIQUE)` + promote the inert
`groups.owner_project` (0047) to a real FK (ON DELETE SET NULL) + index.
- CLI mints a stable, gitignored project key in `.picloud/project.json`
(`pic init`, or lazily on first tree plan/apply) and presents it on every
tree request; `pic apply --dir --takeover` flag.
- Server: prepare_tree resolves ownership read-only (plan surfaces conflicts
+ prune candidates; token folds each group's owner key). apply_tree upserts
the project in-tx, claims created groups on insert, reconciles existing-group
ownership under the per-node advisory lock (first-commit-wins), and prunes
owned-but-undeclared groups leaf-first (delete=RESTRICT, never another repo's
or a UI-owned node).
- Authz (§7.4, ownership ⟂ RBAC): takeover requires GroupAdmin per contested
node — enforced in authz_tree (pre-tx) AND re-verified in-tx at the ownership
decision, so --force (which waives the staleness token) can't open a
takeover-without-admin window. The attacker-supplied project key is
length/charset-validated server-side.
- Tests: tests/ownership.rs (claim → conflict → takeover → flip; non-admin
takeover → 403; prune-owned-only); format_conflicts unit test; schema golden
reblessed. tree_shape M2 journey updated to reparent in-place (a fresh dir is
now a distinct project and would correctly conflict).
Closes the M3 milestone; reviewed (4 findings: 1 authz-bypass via --force +
key validation + 2 LOW, all fixed). M4 (trigger/route templates) remains.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two journeys against a live server + Postgres:
- `group_module_is_lexically_sealed_under_inheritance`: a group module +
a group endpoint that imports it, inherited by an app — proves the §5.5
trust boundary (a leaf's same-named module does NOT shadow the inherited
endpoint's import) and app-origin CoW (an app endpoint's import resolves
the app's module).
- `dangling_import_is_rejected_by_plan`: a manifest script importing a
non-existent module is a `pic plan` error.
Docs: mark §5.5 residual resolved + §11 Phase 4b ✅ in the design doc;
update CLAUDE.md current-focus (extension points are the remaining §5.5
piece).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 5 C5. Three `pic ... --dir` tree journeys:
* a group + a nested app apply atomically as one tree (the app's route binds
the group's same-apply `shared` script); the group node's script is
created; re-plan is all-noop (idempotent),
* one invalid node aborts the whole tree — the valid group node's script is
NOT created (true all-or-nothing),
* a `pic groups reparent` between `pic plan --dir` and `pic apply --dir` trips
the bound-plan (StateMoved) check via the tree's structure version.
Docs: `groups-and-project-tool.md` §11.5 status (✅ shipped — single-repo
nested tree apply; multi-repo single-owner + per-env approval gating deferred
per §11.1) + CLAUDE.md current-focus.
Gates: fmt, clippy -D warnings, cargo test --workspace, check-versioning (50
migrations — Phase 5 added none), schema snapshot unchanged, full journey suite
108/108. (Pre-existing flake `queue_e2e::queue_receive_acks_on_success` — a
racy immediate `count==0` after the async ack; flaky at the pre-Phase-5
baseline too, unrelated to this work.)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Mark §11.4 ✅ shipped with the live-resolution decision (no body
materialization / invalidation fan-out, mirroring Phase 3's config), the
shipped surface, and the deliberate Phase-4b deferrals (group modules + lexical
import resolver, invoke-by-id, live auto-rebinding). Note the sharp edge:
routes.script_id ON DELETE CASCADE means deleting a group script drops
descendant routes. Update the §5.1 materialization box and CLAUDE.md
(current-focus + the data-model invariant now covers group-owned scripts).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The groups/project-tool work had no home in the blueprint's version
scheme, two "Phase N" numbering schemes overlapped, and CLAUDE.md's
"current focus" was stale (claimed v1.1.0 SDK foundation; we're at v1.1.9
with the SDK line complete). Reconcile all three:
* blueprint §12 Phase 5 (v1.2, already titled "Advanced Workflows &
Hierarchies") — split into a Hierarchies track (the groups + project
tool initiative, with §11 Phases 1–3 marked shipped) and a Workflows
track, with sequencing flagged as an open call. This gives the work an
explicit version home: the Hierarchies half of v1.2.
* design doc header — Status Draft → Active, "scheduled as the Hierarchies
track of v1.2", and an explicit warning that §11's local Phase 1–6
numbering is distinct from the blueprint product-phase numbering.
* design doc §11.1 — a post-Phase-3 re-sequencing review: resolve Phase 4
scripts LIVE (drop the fan-out-invalidation sub-project, per the Phase 3
result); consider a "Phase 5-lite" (declarative apply of vars/secrets +
app scripts) before the hard group-scripts work; and force the two
deferred decisions (trigger/route templates vs tenant cardinality;
multi-repo ownership vs a single-repo start).
* CLAUDE.md — refresh "current focus" to v1.2 Hierarchies, and correct the
now-broken "every v1.1+ table is app_id NOT NULL" invariant: the new
group-inheritable config tables (vars, secrets) use a polymorphic owner
(group_id XOR app_id), not app_id NOT NULL.
Doc-only; no code change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 3 (group-inherited config) is implemented, so fold the outcome back
into the design doc (per its own "before it drifts" note) — and flag the
one deliberate divergence from the plan.
§5.1 / §11.3 / §12 prescribed a *materialized* per-app effective view with
a generation counter and fan-out invalidation. We shipped **live,
resolve-on-read inheritance** instead: one recursive CTE per
`vars::get`/`secrets::get`/`config/effective`, no cache. The org tree is
small and there was no pre-existing config cache to fight, so this is
cheap and sidesteps §10's unsolved invalidation SLA.
Records, mirroring the Phase 1/2 status blocks:
* a "Status (Phase 3): ✅ shipped" block in §11.3 with the full surface
(0048/0049 schema incl. `apps.environment`, the §3 resolver, vars SDK +
CRUD, group-secret AAD + inherited read, the two secret gates, masked
`config/effective`, `--explain`) and the live-vs-materialized rationale;
* §5.1 runtime-model bullet annotated as the deferred (Phase-4 script
inheritance) design, not Phase-3 runtime;
* §10 "invalidation SLA" and "inherited-membership revocation lag" marked
moot/resolved — no cache means immediate propagation;
* §12 resolver contract + the header framing updated to live resolution.
Doc-only; no code change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Update §4.3: the fire-time `enabled` re-check is shipped and test-backed on
BOTH async arms (the unified outbox `!resolved.active` gate and the queue
arm's fresh-script nack), with the specific regression tests cited, plus the
same-app backstop now present on every async build path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Fold the implementation outcome back into the project-tool spec (§11) as
the design asks. Records what landed (init/pull/config/plan/apply/prune,
env overlays, enabled lifecycle, trigger name+backfill, content-fingerprint
bound-plan, apply lock) and the deliberate deferrals: tree-structure
version → groups; vars/--explain → Phase 3; trigger upsert-by-name + the
dashboard enabled toggle → tracked follow-ups beyond the §11 bullets.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The architecture spec for the full vision — a declarative project tool
(picloud.toml + pull/plan/apply/prune) and a server-side nested-groups
hierarchy with live-resolve inheritance. Reviewed across several passes
for consistency, gaps, and contradictions; resolutions are folded in
beside the topics they settle.
This commit lands the spec only. The first slice of implementation (the
single-app reconcile foundation) follows; groups, env-scoping, and the
`enabled` toggle are later milestones called out in the doc.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
