The endurance test refuted the sliding-window model I committed earlier. A keepalive doing only GET /api/v3/me succeeded at t+0/30/60/90 and was still rejected by t+120 — consistent with the session ending ~2h after LOGIN (t+107), and inconsistent with 2h after the last request, which would have been t+210. This is a live-vs-source divergence, not a misreading: both the current JwtWhitelistAdapter and the legacy Feathers ensureTokenIsWhitelisted re-set the Valkey TTL on every authenticated request, so the source reads as a sliding window. The instance does not behave that way. So the keepalive now calls POST /authentication/refresh-session, the endpoint behind the UI's "Sitzung verlängern" button, which a separate 100s test showed does hold the reported budget at 7200s. It is the only non-GET request in the server: no body, touches only our own session, cannot read or modify user data, and is not exposed as a tool, so no model-driven call can ever be a POST. It logs the returned budget, which makes a failing extension visible before the session is lost. Whether this is sufficient is NOT established. Two mechanisms still fit: an idle TTL that reads fail to refresh (keepalive works), or an absolute cap/revocation anchored at login — e.g. the IDP's back-channel logout, which clears every token for the account rather than one. Added scripts/session-diagnose.mjs to settle it: it logs the budget every 10 min, so a decaying series indicates the former and an abrupt 401 at 7200s the latter. Docs state the open question rather than asserting a mechanism. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
8.8 KiB
Authentication
What this server uses
The jwt cookie from a logged-in browser session, sent verbatim as
Authorization: Bearer <token>. That is the whole mechanism.
This was worth confirming rather than assuming, because the obvious reading of "it's a cookie" leads somewhere much more complicated. Verified live:
Authorization: Bearer <jwt> → 200 # what this server does
Cookie: jwt=<jwt> → 200 # also works
(no auth) → 401
connect.sid, SERVERID and isLoggedIn are not needed — there is no
cookie jar. There is a session to keep alive, though not in the way the
cookies suggest; see the next section.
Token lifetime: what the source says, and what the instance does
Two clocks govern the token, and only one of them is in the JWT:
| Clock | Value | Moves with use? |
|---|---|---|
| Session — a whitelist entry in the server's Valkey store | ends ~2 h after login | No (measured) |
Hard expiry — the JWT's own exp claim |
30 days | No (cannot be extended) |
The token dies at whichever comes first. Decoding the JWT shows only the second, which is how "valid for 30 days" becomes a plausible and wrong conclusion — it was the first conclusion drawn here, and it is wrong.
What the source says
JwtStrategy.validate() runs on every route behind @JwtAuthentication() and
calls JwtWhitelistAdapter.isWhitelisted(accountId, jti), which reads Valkey
key jwt:{accountId}:{jti}, throws
'Session was expired due to inactivity - autologout.' if it is gone, and then
re-sets the key with a fresh JWT_TIMEOUT_SECONDS TTL. The legacy Feathers
implementation it replaced (ensureTokenIsWhitelisted) does the same thing,
with the comment "extend token expiration if token is already whitelisted".
Read on its own, that says the window slides with ordinary use.
What the instance actually does
It does not slide. A keepalive doing nothing but GET /api/v3/me every 30
minutes was measured against the live instance:
[t+0.0min] ping #1 -> 200 OK
[t+30.0min] ping #2 -> 200 OK
[t+60.0min] ping #3 -> 200 OK
[t+90.0min] ping #4 -> 200 OK
[t+120.0min] 401 Unauthorized ← token gone
The timing is what makes this conclusive:
| If the limit were… | Predicted death | Observed? |
|---|---|---|
| 2 h after the last request | t+210 min | no — died by t+120 |
| 2 h after login | t+107 min (login was ~t−13) | yes — inside the (t+90, t+120] window |
Four requests succeeded inside the window and bought nothing. The binding clock is anchored at login, and ordinary reads do not move it.
A separate 100-second test does show POST /authentication/refresh-session
holding the reported budget at 7200 s rather than letting it decay to ~7100, so
that endpoint does something the reads do not.
Values the instance publishes
Unauthenticated, so you can check them any time:
curl -s "$TSC_URL/api/v3/config/public" | jq '{JWT_TIMEOUT_SECONDS, JWT_SHOW_TIMEOUT_WARNING_SECONDS}'
# { "JWT_TIMEOUT_SECONDS": 7200, "JWT_SHOW_TIMEOUT_WARNING_SECONDS": 3600 }
7200 s matches the observed ~2 h, and JWT_SHOW_TIMEOUT_WARNING_SECONDS: 3600
is exactly the web UI's prompt one hour in, warning of expiry an hour later,
with a "Sitzung verlängern" button. That the prompt appears at all is itself
evidence: if ordinary activity extended the session, an actively used portal
would never show it.
The open question
Two mechanisms fit the evidence, and they differ in what they mean for this server:
- An idle TTL that ordinary reads fail to refresh. Then explicitly calling
refresh-sessionon a timer holds the session indefinitely, up to the 30-day hard expiry, and the keepalive below is the whole fix. - An absolute cap at login + 2 h, or revocation from outside — for
instance the identity provider ending its SSO session, whose back-channel
logout (
POST /api/v3/logout/oidc→removeUserFromWhitelist(account)) clears every token for the account, not just one. Then no keepalive can help, and a pasted JWT is only ever good for ~2 h from login.
npm run session-diagnose settles it. It calls refresh-session every 10
minutes and logs the reported budget, so the shape of the log at death is the
answer: a budget decaying 7200 → 0 means (1); a budget sitting at 7200 until an
abrupt 401 means (2).
Note that plain POST /api/v3/logout removes only its own jti, so logging
out in a browser does not kill this server's token. Only the OIDC
back-channel variant clears all of them.
There is no longer window available
config/default.schema.json documents JWT_EXTENDED_TIMEOUT_SECONDS
(2629746 s ≈ 1 month), reachable in the legacy stack via a privateDevice
login flag. On the current NestJS server that is vestigial: privateDevice has
no references in apps/server/src, and generateJwtAndAddToWhitelist calls
addToWhitelist with no TTL override. A "remember me" login will not buy a
longer window.
How this server tries to stay alive
src/keepalive.ts calls POST /api/v3/authentication/refresh-session every 30
minutes (KEEPALIVE_INTERVAL_MS; 0 disables it), started by both entry
points, independent of whether any MCP client is connected — the session
expires on wall time, not on usage. It logs the budget each time, so the log
shows whether the extension is taking:
[schulcloud-mcp] keepalive: session extended, 7200s (120 min) of budget left
A budget well under 7200 s is the early warning that the session is being lost.
A transient failure retries in 5 minutes; a 401 stops the keepalive
permanently and says what to do, because a cleared whitelist entry cannot be
revived by retrying.
This is the one non-GET request in the server. It takes no body, touches
only the caller's own session, and cannot read or modify user data, so it does
not weaken the property that matters — nobody reaching this endpoint can act as
the user inside Schulcloud. No MCP tool exposes it, so a model-driven call can
never be a POST. A plain GET was tried first and is what the endurance test
above ruled out.
Whether this is sufficient is not yet established. If
npm run session-diagnose reports mechanism (2), the keepalive cannot work and
the auth approach itself needs revisiting.
Operational consequence either way: if the container is down for more than two hours, the token is dead when it returns and restarting will not fix it. The startup log says so immediately:
[schulcloud-mcp] keepalive: token rejected (401). The session is gone …
Why not username + password
The instance's login redirects to Keycloak (realm TIS) with a redirect_uri
pointing back at Schulcloud's own server, so the authorization-code exchange
happens server-side with a client secret only Schulcloud holds. A third party
cannot replicate that flow. POST /api/v3/authentication/local exists but is
for accounts with local credentials, which federated school accounts do not
have.
Whether the pasted-JWT approach remains the right trade depends on the open question above. If a keepalive can hold a session to its 30-day ceiling, it is: one manual step a month against re-implementing an OAuth client whose secret we cannot hold. If the session is instead capped at ~2 h from login, a pasted JWT is not viable for an unattended server, and the realistic options become a service account issued by the school's IDM, or driving the Keycloak login with a headless browser. If this ever needs to be unattended, the honest options are a service account issued by the school's IDM, or a headless browser login — not a reimplementation of the Keycloak exchange.
Protecting this server's own endpoint
Distinct from the above, and just as important. The MCP endpoint is reachable
from the public internet by construction: Claude's connectors call it from
Anthropic's cloud, not from your machine. It is protected by MCP_AUTH_TOKEN,
a shared secret checked in constant time on every /mcp request
(src/http/auth.ts), accepted as either Authorization: Bearer … or
X-Api-Key. /healthz is deliberately open and reveals nothing.
Generate one with openssl rand -hex 32. If it is unset the server logs a loud
warning and serves unauthenticated — only acceptable bound to localhost.
Rotating it: change MCP_AUTH_TOKEN in .env, restart the container, update
the connector in Claude. Nothing else stores it.
Blast radius
Every path in this server is a GET, including the api_get escape hatch,
which rejects anything not starting with /api/ and anything carrying a scheme
or host. Someone who obtained both the endpoint URL and MCP_AUTH_TOKEN could
read this account's Schulcloud data; they could not post, submit, delete, or
otherwise act as the user. Keep it that way — adding a single write tool would
change that property entirely.