re: the title's build-in measured in the guest's draw stream -- the flashes are real
The settle-time decode was confirmed only against a SETTLED frame, which shows the end state is right and says nothing about whether the five flashes ever happen. This runs the oracle: a draw capture armed before the title exists, so the window contains the frames in which the screen is built. The flashes fire in a six-frame window and are absent from all 155 other sampled frames. `ptlogo_back2eff1` is drawn in exactly two frames at t = 54.0 against a decoded peak of t54-56; `ptlogo1` first appears at t = 42.2 against a decoded t42. Units-per-frame was taken from the GLOW's period alone, a different element, so the timings are not circular. The two holders are continuous from frame 134. The plate glow's quad carries a per-vertex colour whose alpha IS the element's fade alpha, so the ramp is read straight out of the guest: observed range 0..80 against a decoded peak of 80, exact and unfitted; period 51.158 presented frames over 20 cycle starts. Fitting the decoded ramp gives RMS 13.16 alpha levels against 38.18 for the same ramp REVERSED -- if the shape carried no information those would be equal, so the asymmetry is real and correctly directed. Further controls: symmetric triangle 15.73, flat 31.13. `ptlogo_back2eff3` was never drawn, and that is expected rather than a miss: a 2-unit flash peak is 0.85 of a presented frame, so catching one is a matter of phase. A port drawing all five every time shows more sweep than the console. METHOD.md gains the trap this cost: a 2D draw's identity is its vertex geometry, not its bound texture. These sprites sample shared pages, and matching texture dimensions produced a false negative (no flash is ever drawn) and a false positive (the intro movie's 640x360 YUV planes read as `ptbase2`) in the same pass. Also records the top-level restriction on the settle window, which the port raised and which is verified here: top-level [160,236] width 76, including the `ptloop` leaves [269,540] width 271 -- an instant past the end of every top-level element's timeline. Evidence committed as a derived per-frame series, not the 7 MB raw log. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com> Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01QsEPXWVaEpyfudtR6re1Pd
This commit is contained in:
@@ -1059,3 +1059,24 @@ The general trap: **an aggregate computed per-element is not a state of the
|
||||
system.** Ask what instant a composite claims to depict, and check that every
|
||||
element was asked the same question. See
|
||||
[`structures/ui-settle-time.md`](structures/ui-settle-time.md).
|
||||
|
||||
## A 2D draw's identity is its geometry, not its bound texture
|
||||
|
||||
The title's sprites **sample large shared texture pages**, so the texture bound to
|
||||
a draw identifies a page and not an element. Matching a bound texture's dimensions
|
||||
against a decoded sprite's fails silently in both directions, and one pass here
|
||||
did both at once:
|
||||
|
||||
* **false negative** — "none of the five flash sprites is ever drawn". They are
|
||||
drawn; they simply never appear as their own texture.
|
||||
* **false positive** — "`ptbase2` (640×360) and `pteff04` (1280×720) are drawn in
|
||||
frames 75–105". Those frames are the **intro movie**, whose YUV planes and
|
||||
target happen to be 640×360 and 1280×720.
|
||||
|
||||
Re-run against the **quad's vertex rect** in design space and every element
|
||||
appears where the disc says it should. Canary's own capture code already carries
|
||||
this warning in a comment, and the corpus had already recorded that the settled
|
||||
title binds only 1280×768 pages — both were there to be read first.
|
||||
|
||||
The general shape: **a coincidence of size is not an identification.** Before
|
||||
matching on one attribute, ask what else in the frame shares it.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user