re: making turrets targets does not save the escort — the effect is inside the noise
The Stage-02 outcome write-up ended by naming "turrets near the asset must become targets" as the fix worth ~50% of the escort damage. That was an inference from a co-presence attribution, not a measurement. Run it and it does not hold. Also corrects the run labelling: pilot.py gained the SYLPH_KILL_TURRETS gate two minutes before mission02 started, so mission02 was already a treatment run, not a second baseline. Only mission01 (0 of 3968 pilot frames targeting a turret) is the baseline. At a common t=428s: baseline 46.9% escort hull, treatment 44.5% and 53.0%. The two runs of the same arm differ by more than either differs from the baseline, and the escort still reaches zero at t~590-670s in all three. So the transferable finding is the power limit: one 430s flight cannot resolve an effect below ~9 percentage points, and every single-run pilot conclusion, including this one's, is inside it. What does reproduce: the assault is scripted (onset 166/167/166s), and the e007/e010 damage split is 50/50 in all three arms including the one that never fires at a turret -- so that attribution measures the wave script, not us. Also records that the viewer's include_external hypothesis in BACKLOG is dead (it defaults true and is threaded through unchanged).
This commit is contained in:
161
docs/re/captures/escort-decay-ab.csv
Normal file
161
docs/re/captures/escort-decay-ab.csv
Normal file
@@ -0,0 +1,161 @@
|
||||
run,turret_rule,t_s,acropolis_hull,e007_alive,e007_killed_cum
|
||||
mission01,off,0,25000.0,0,0
|
||||
mission01,off,10,25000.0,5,0
|
||||
mission01,off,20,25000.0,6,0
|
||||
mission01,off,30,25000.0,6,0
|
||||
mission01,off,40,25000.0,6,0
|
||||
mission01,off,50,25000.0,8,0
|
||||
mission01,off,60,25000.0,11,0
|
||||
mission01,off,70,25000.0,11,3
|
||||
mission01,off,80,25000.0,8,3
|
||||
mission01,off,90,25000.0,8,3
|
||||
mission01,off,100,25000.0,10,3
|
||||
mission01,off,110,25000.0,14,3
|
||||
mission01,off,120,25000.0,16,3
|
||||
mission01,off,130,25000.0,17,3
|
||||
mission01,off,140,25000.0,20,3
|
||||
mission01,off,150,25000.0,23,3
|
||||
mission01,off,160,25000.0,26,4
|
||||
mission01,off,170,24509.5,33,4
|
||||
mission01,off,180,24509.5,37,4
|
||||
mission01,off,190,24419.5,38,5
|
||||
mission01,off,200,24212.5,41,5
|
||||
mission01,off,210,23447.5,40,5
|
||||
mission01,off,220,23447.5,40,5
|
||||
mission01,off,220,23447.5,40,5
|
||||
mission01,off,230,23447.5,41,5
|
||||
mission01,off,230,23447.5,41,5
|
||||
mission01,off,240,22912.0,43,5
|
||||
mission01,off,240,22867.0,43,5
|
||||
mission01,off,250,22667.0,42,6
|
||||
mission01,off,250,22647.0,42,6
|
||||
mission01,off,260,22334.5,44,6
|
||||
mission01,off,260,22177.9,44,6
|
||||
mission01,off,270,21101.2,46,6
|
||||
mission01,off,270,21101.2,45,6
|
||||
mission01,off,280,20292.6,46,6
|
||||
mission01,off,280,20279.1,46,6
|
||||
mission01,off,290,19598.5,58,6
|
||||
mission01,off,290,19598.5,58,6
|
||||
mission01,off,300,18725.2,58,6
|
||||
mission01,off,300,18658.5,47,6
|
||||
mission01,off,310,18231.9,47,6
|
||||
mission01,off,310,18231.9,47,6
|
||||
mission01,off,320,17425.2,47,6
|
||||
mission01,off,330,17046.9,49,6
|
||||
mission01,off,340,16044.8,49,7
|
||||
mission01,off,350,15461.5,50,7
|
||||
mission01,off,360,14956.3,51,7
|
||||
mission01,off,370,14425.5,51,8
|
||||
mission01,off,380,13910.5,51,8
|
||||
mission01,off,390,13418.9,49,11
|
||||
mission01,off,400,13218.9,45,12
|
||||
mission01,off,410,12517.9,44,12
|
||||
mission01,off,420,12161.3,44,13
|
||||
mission01,off,430,11601.3,44,13
|
||||
mission02,on,0,25000.0,0,0
|
||||
mission02,on,10,25000.0,5,0
|
||||
mission02,on,20,25000.0,6,0
|
||||
mission02,on,30,25000.0,5,0
|
||||
mission02,on,40,25000.0,5,1
|
||||
mission02,on,50,25000.0,7,1
|
||||
mission02,on,60,25000.0,10,1
|
||||
mission02,on,70,25000.0,7,4
|
||||
mission02,on,80,25000.0,7,4
|
||||
mission02,on,90,25000.0,7,4
|
||||
mission02,on,100,25000.0,7,4
|
||||
mission02,on,110,25000.0,9,4
|
||||
mission02,on,120,25000.0,14,4
|
||||
mission02,on,130,25000.0,16,4
|
||||
mission02,on,140,25000.0,19,4
|
||||
mission02,on,150,25000.0,19,4
|
||||
mission02,on,160,25000.0,23,5
|
||||
mission02,on,170,24730.0,28,5
|
||||
mission02,on,180,24730.0,32,5
|
||||
mission02,on,190,24730.0,36,5
|
||||
mission02,on,200,24640.0,43,6
|
||||
mission02,on,210,24190.0,46,6
|
||||
mission02,on,220,24055.0,47,6
|
||||
mission02,on,220,24055.0,47,6
|
||||
mission02,on,230,24055.0,49,6
|
||||
mission02,on,230,24055.0,49,6
|
||||
mission02,on,240,23474.5,52,6
|
||||
mission02,on,240,23474.5,52,6
|
||||
mission02,on,250,23474.5,53,6
|
||||
mission02,on,250,23474.5,53,6
|
||||
mission02,on,260,23474.5,54,6
|
||||
mission02,on,260,23474.5,54,6
|
||||
mission02,on,270,22697.0,54,6
|
||||
mission02,on,270,22697.0,54,6
|
||||
mission02,on,280,22091.2,56,6
|
||||
mission02,on,280,22091.2,55,7
|
||||
mission02,on,290,21577.9,55,7
|
||||
mission02,on,290,21555.4,55,7
|
||||
mission02,on,300,20799.1,56,7
|
||||
mission02,on,310,19781.1,55,7
|
||||
mission02,on,320,18925.8,56,8
|
||||
mission02,on,330,18592.5,56,8
|
||||
mission02,on,340,17432.5,57,8
|
||||
mission02,on,350,16932.6,59,8
|
||||
mission02,on,360,16171.6,58,9
|
||||
mission02,on,370,15017.6,58,11
|
||||
mission02,on,380,14217.2,59,11
|
||||
mission02,on,390,13322.2,59,12
|
||||
mission02,on,400,12808.9,58,13
|
||||
mission02,on,410,12090.6,61,16
|
||||
mission02,on,420,11440.6,66,19
|
||||
mission02,on,430,11127.3,55,19
|
||||
mission03,on,0,25000.0,0,0
|
||||
mission03,on,10,25000.0,3,0
|
||||
mission03,on,20,25000.0,8,0
|
||||
mission03,on,30,25000.0,5,0
|
||||
mission03,on,40,25000.0,6,0
|
||||
mission03,on,50,25000.0,8,0
|
||||
mission03,on,60,25000.0,9,0
|
||||
mission03,on,70,25000.0,16,0
|
||||
mission03,on,80,25000.0,10,0
|
||||
mission03,on,90,25000.0,11,0
|
||||
mission03,on,100,25000.0,10,2
|
||||
mission03,on,110,25000.0,15,2
|
||||
mission03,on,120,25000.0,12,2
|
||||
mission03,on,130,25000.0,10,4
|
||||
mission03,on,140,25000.0,11,6
|
||||
mission03,on,150,25000.0,14,6
|
||||
mission03,on,160,25000.0,17,7
|
||||
mission03,on,170,24685.0,24,7
|
||||
mission03,on,180,24640.0,23,7
|
||||
mission03,on,190,24640.0,27,7
|
||||
mission03,on,200,24460.0,26,8
|
||||
mission03,on,210,24100.0,28,8
|
||||
mission03,on,220,24100.0,29,9
|
||||
mission03,on,230,24100.0,28,11
|
||||
mission03,on,230,24100.0,28,11
|
||||
mission03,on,240,23810.0,35,11
|
||||
mission03,on,240,23810.0,36,11
|
||||
mission03,on,250,23630.0,36,12
|
||||
mission03,on,250,23630.0,36,12
|
||||
mission03,on,260,23630.0,38,13
|
||||
mission03,on,260,23630.0,38,13
|
||||
mission03,on,270,22998.0,39,13
|
||||
mission03,on,270,22908.0,39,13
|
||||
mission03,on,280,22197.5,40,13
|
||||
mission03,on,280,22188.5,40,13
|
||||
mission03,on,290,21602.4,38,13
|
||||
mission03,on,290,21602.4,38,13
|
||||
mission03,on,300,21042.4,39,13
|
||||
mission03,on,300,20975.8,39,13
|
||||
mission03,on,310,20529.1,41,15
|
||||
mission03,on,310,20529.1,41,15
|
||||
mission03,on,320,19812.5,38,17
|
||||
mission03,on,320,19767.5,38,17
|
||||
mission03,on,330,19434.2,39,18
|
||||
mission03,on,340,18785.9,37,19
|
||||
mission03,on,350,18339.2,37,19
|
||||
mission03,on,360,17528.1,38,19
|
||||
mission03,on,370,16901.5,37,19
|
||||
mission03,on,380,16260.7,35,19
|
||||
mission03,on,390,15708.2,37,19
|
||||
mission03,on,400,15346.2,37,19
|
||||
mission03,on,410,14412.1,36,20
|
||||
mission03,on,420,13951.9,37,22
|
||||
mission03,on,430,13211.9,35,23
|
||||
|
BIN
docs/re/captures/mission03-turretrule-t430.png
Normal file
BIN
docs/re/captures/mission03-turretrule-t430.png
Normal file
Binary file not shown.
|
After Width: | Height: | Size: 1.3 MiB |
Reference in New Issue
Block a user