Add the runtime heart of extension points: `ModuleSource::resolve_policy`
decides lexical vs dynamic resolution by the NEAREST declaration of a name
walking up the importing origin's chain — a concrete module → lexical (seal
to origin, Phase 4b); an extension-point marker → dynamic, resolved against
the inheriting app (`cx.app_id`) so the app can override, falling back to the
default body up-chain; the EP wins a depth tie.
- shared: `ModuleResolution { Module | NoProvider | NotFound }` + a
`resolve_policy(origin, inheriting_app, name)` trait method with a
lexical-only default impl (existing fakes inherit it unchanged).
- PostgresModuleSource: one-round-trip nearest-declaration query (min EP depth
vs min module depth over the chain CTEs), then the lexical/dynamic branch.
- module_resolver: calls `resolve_policy(origin, cx.app_id, path)`; maps
NoProvider → a clear "extension point has no provider" error, NotFound →
module-not-found. Cache + AST-source sealing unchanged.
- executor-core tests: a policy fake + 3 cases (app override binds dynamically,
no-provider errors, non-EP stays lexical).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
An extension point (§5.5) marks a module name a node offers for descendants
to provide/override — resolved dynamically against the inheriting app rather
than lexically sealed. Lay the storage:
- migration 0051: owner-polymorphic `extension_points(id, group_id?, app_id?,
name)` marker table — exactly-one CHECK + per-owner partial-unique LOWER(name)
indexes + lookup indexes (mirrors 0050). ON DELETE CASCADE (a marker is
config, not code). No default-body column — the optional default body is a
co-located kind=module script (Phase 4b stores/resolves/caches those).
- extension_point_repo: `list_for_owner` + idempotent `insert_extension_point_tx`
/ `delete_extension_point_tx`, keyed by the shared `ScriptOwner` (mirrors the
var/secret tx-fn style).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adversarial-review finding: `create_group_script` validated every source
with `validate()` regardless of kind, so an imperatively-created group
module (`pic scripts deploy --group g --name kv --kind module`) skipped the
two gates every other module-write path enforces (app create/update in
api.rs, declarative apply in apply_service): the stricter `validate_module`
shape check and the `RESERVED_MODULE_NAMES` guard. A malformed-shape group
module was accepted at create (only failing later at import-resolve time)
and a reserved name (`kv`, `log`, …) slipped through.
Branch on kind to mirror the app path. Adds a journey asserting a reserved
group-module name is rejected.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two journeys against a live server + Postgres:
- `group_module_is_lexically_sealed_under_inheritance`: a group module +
a group endpoint that imports it, inherited by an app — proves the §5.5
trust boundary (a leaf's same-named module does NOT shadow the inherited
endpoint's import) and app-origin CoW (an app endpoint's import resolves
the app's module).
- `dangling_import_is_rejected_by_plan`: a manifest script importing a
non-existent module is a `pic plan` error.
Docs: mark §5.5 residual resolved + §11 Phase 4b ✅ in the design doc;
update CLAUDE.md current-focus (extension points are the remaining §5.5
piece).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Lift the Phase-4-lite restrictions now that import resolution is lexical:
- `create_group_script` (group_scripts_api): allow `kind = module` and
group scripts with `import`s; record the import edges. Module-shape and
sandbox-ceiling validation stay.
- The declarative apply path already reconciles group modules generically
(`BundleScript.kind` + `owner.script_owner()` flow through
`reconcile_node_tx`); no change needed beyond stale-comment fixes.
Adds the §5.5 dangling-import plan check (single-node plan/apply):
`check_imports_resolve` rejects an `import "<m>"` that resolves to neither a
bundle-local module nor a module reachable lexically up the node's chain —
caught at plan time instead of as a runtime 404. Roots resolution at the
node's owner (an app node reaches ancestor group modules; a group node walks
its own ancestry). ApplyService gains an injected `ModuleSource`. The tree
path opts out (a node may import a module created by another node in the same
uncommitted tx); the runtime check is the backstop there.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Make `import` resolution lexical (§5.5): an inherited group script's
imports resolve against the module set at its OWN defining node, walking
up from there — a leaf app can't shadow them, and a group script behaves
identically under every inheriting app.
Mechanism — Rhai's `_source` carries the importing AST's origin tag:
- The entry script has no source tag → resolve from `default_origin` (its
defining node, threaded in via C2).
- Each resolved module's AST source is set to `encode(module.owner())`
before `eval_ast_as_new`, so its nested `import`s carry the module's own
node as `_source` and resolve from there — lexical chaining.
- `encode_origin`/`decode_origin` map a `ScriptOwner` to/from `app:<uuid>`
/ `group:<uuid>`.
Cache rekeyed from `(app_id, name)` to the resolved `ScriptId`: a compiled
module is lexically self-contained, so its body is a pure function of
`(script_id, updated_at)` — this also dedupes a shared group module across
inheriting apps and keeps same-named cross-app modules distinct.
Adds two executor-core unit tests (origin-keyed fake) proving the trust
boundary: a group module's import binds the group's module even when an
app-owned module of the same name exists; `ScriptOwner` gains `Hash`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Carry the resolved script's owner (its defining node) from dispatch into
the executor so `import` resolution can be lexical (§5.5). The executing
app (`app_id`) stays the SDK isolation boundary; `script_owner` is a
separate axis — the lexical origin for imports.
- `ExecRequest.script_owner: Option<ScriptOwner>` (serde default; `None`
falls back to `App(app_id)` in the engine for old payloads / cluster wire).
- `ScriptOwner` gains `Serialize`/`Deserialize` for the wire.
- The engine computes `default_origin` and hands it to the resolver
(used fully in C3; the resolve() lookup already uses it).
- Every dispatch site sets it from the resolved `Script.owner()`:
the 4 dispatcher arms (queue/trigger/http/invoke_async, via a new
`ResolvedTrigger.script_owner`), the orchestrator id-bypass, and the
`invoke()` SDK path (new `ResolvedScript.owner`, so a group script
invoked by an app resolves imports from the group).
Behaviour-preserving: app scripts still resolve `App(app_id)`; group
scripts can't yet carry imports (lifted in C4).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Make the module-loading contract origin-aware so group-owned modules
become resolvable and imports can resolve lexically (§5.5).
- `ModuleScript` gains a polymorphic owner (`app_id`/`group_id` + `owner()`),
mirroring `Script`.
- `ModuleSource::lookup(&cx, name)` -> `resolve(origin: ScriptOwner, name)`:
resolution walks the group chain rooted at the importing script's
defining node (nearest-owner-wins), not the inheriting app's view.
- `PostgresModuleSource::resolve` branches on origin: app-rooted
(`CHAIN_LEVELS_CTE`) or a new group-rooted `GROUP_CHAIN_LEVELS_CTE`,
joining `kind='module'` rows.
The executor resolver passes a temporary `App(cx.app_id)` origin (behaviour-
preserving for app scripts; true lexical origin lands in C3). Group scripts
still can't carry imports until C4, so no trust-inversion window opens here.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 5 C5. Three `pic ... --dir` tree journeys:
* a group + a nested app apply atomically as one tree (the app's route binds
the group's same-apply `shared` script); the group node's script is
created; re-plan is all-noop (idempotent),
* one invalid node aborts the whole tree — the valid group node's script is
NOT created (true all-or-nothing),
* a `pic groups reparent` between `pic plan --dir` and `pic apply --dir` trips
the bound-plan (StateMoved) check via the tree's structure version.
Docs: `groups-and-project-tool.md` §11.5 status (✅ shipped — single-repo
nested tree apply; multi-repo single-owner + per-env approval gating deferred
per §11.1) + CLAUDE.md current-focus.
Gates: fmt, clippy -D warnings, cargo test --workspace, check-versioning (50
migrations — Phase 5 added none), schema snapshot unchanged, full journey suite
108/108. (Pre-existing flake `queue_e2e::queue_receive_acks_on_success` — a
racy immediate `count==0` after the async ack; flaky at the pre-Phase-5
baseline too, unrelated to this work.)
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 5 C4. `pic plan --dir <root>` / `pic apply --dir <root>` discover every
`picloud.toml` under a directory (groups + apps), assemble the wire tree
bundle, and drive the C3 `/tree/{plan,apply}` endpoints — a whole project
subtree reconciled and reviewed as one unit.
* New `discover` module: recursive walk (skips `.picloud`/`.git`/`scripts`/
`target`), one node per manifest, app/group inferred from the manifest;
rejects a duplicate (kind, slug). On-disk nesting is organizational — the
server resolves ancestry from its own group tree.
* `client`: `plan_tree`/`apply_tree` + `TreePlanDto`/`NodePlanDto`. `pic plan
--dir` renders a per-node diff table and records ONE tree bound-token under
a `<tree>` linkstate marker; `pic apply --dir` replays it (force/`--yes`/
prune apply tree-wide). `--dir` conflicts with `--file`.
Live-validated: a nested tree (root group dir + nested app dir, app route bound
to the group's inherited script) → `pic plan --dir .` shows both nodes' changes
→ `pic apply --dir .` applies all in one tx → re-plan all-noop.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 5 C3 — the headline. A whole project subtree (group + app nodes) is
reconciled in ONE Postgres transaction, all-or-nothing.
`POST /api/v1/admin/tree/{plan,apply}` take a `TreeBundle { nodes: [{kind,
slug, bundle}] }`. The actor must hold the relevant read/write caps for EVERY
node (per-kind, widened on prune) — `authz_tree` + reusable
`require_{app,group}_node_writes` (now shared with the single-node handlers).
Engine:
* The in-tx reconcile body of `apply_owner` is extracted to `reconcile_node_tx`
(returns the node's post-create `name → script_id`), so single-node and
tree apply share one implementation — behaviour-preserving (391 unit tests
+ app journeys green).
* `prepare_tree` resolves each slug→owner, validates (an app's route/trigger
target may bind to an in-tree ancestor group's script), computes each
node's plan, and folds a combined bound-plan token = every node's
`state_token` + every in-scope group's `structure_version` (so a reparent
or content edit between plan and apply trips StateMoved).
* `apply_tree`: lock every node key (sorted, deadlock-free); reconcile GROUPS
first, recording each group's `name → id` in an in-memory index; then APPS,
resolving inherited route/trigger targets nearest-ancestor-wins across the
in-tree index (incl. scripts created earlier in THIS tx, invisible to the
pool resolver) and pre-existing out-of-tree ancestors. One commit, one
post-commit route refresh.
Live-validated against the dev DB:
* Headline: a group node creates `shared`; an app node in the SAME apply
binds `GET /greet` to it — the route ends up bound to the group-owned
script, and re-plan is all-noop (idempotent).
* Atomicity: one invalid node → 422 and ZERO rows written (the valid group
node's script is not created).
CLI tree discovery + `pic plan/apply` tree mode is C4; journeys + docs are C5.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 5 C2. A `picloud.toml` can now declare a `[group]` node (instead of
`[app]`): the group's own scripts + `[vars]` (+ secret names). `pic plan` /
`pic apply` reconcile it via the C1 group endpoints — the same plan/apply/
bound-token flow as an app, routed by node kind.
* `Manifest` is now app-XOR-group: `app`/`group` are both optional with an
exactly-one check in `parse`, plus a group-node guard that rejects
`[[routes]]`/`[[triggers]]` (those bind to an app). Accessors `slug()` /
`is_group()` replace the hardcoded `manifest.app.slug`.
* `client`: `plan_node`/`apply_node` take a `NodeKind { App | Group }` that
selects the `apps` vs `groups` API path; the old `plan`/`apply` wrappers
are gone (callers pass the kind).
* `pic plan`/`apply` detect the node kind from the manifest and label output
`group`/`app`; `pic config --effective` cleanly rejects a group manifest
(effective config is an app's inherited view).
Live-validated: a `[group]` manifest with a script + var → `pic plan` (script
+ var creates) → `pic apply` (group-owned) → idempotent re-plan noop →
`pic scripts ls --group` shows it. Manifest unit test for group parse +
app-only-block rejection; init/pull/plan/apply/overlay journeys all green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 5 C1. Generalize the reconcile engine from app-only to an `ApplyOwner
{ App | Group }`, so a GROUP's own config + scripts can be declaratively
reconciled — the foundation for the tree-spanning project tool.
A group node is a subset of an app node (scripts + vars only; no routes /
triggers / secrets-values), so the diff, script/route/trigger/var CRUD, prune,
idempotency, and the Phase-4 inherited-target resolution are all reused
unchanged. Only the owner-varying bits switch on `ApplyOwner`:
* `load_current` — `list_for_group` + `VarOwner::Group` for a group (empty
routes/triggers/secrets); `list_for_app` for an app, exactly as before.
* script create owner (`NewScript{app_id|group_id}`), var writes (new
`set_group_var_tx`/`delete_group_var_tx` mirroring the app variants at
scope `*`), and the advisory lock (owner-tagged).
* `validate_bundle_for` rejects routes/triggers on a group bundle (422);
route-host validation, inherited-target resolution, the post-commit route
refresh, and the unreachable-endpoint warning are app-only.
`apply`/`plan` are unchanged thin wrappers over the new `apply_owner`/
`plan_owner`. New endpoints `POST /groups/{id}/{plan,apply}` gated by
`GroupScripts{Read,Write}` / `GroupVarsWrite`. `ApplyService` gains a `groups`
repo (the tree apply in C3 needs it too).
Live-validated: group plan → apply (group-owned script + var) → idempotent
re-plan noop → routes rejected 422 → DB confirms group ownership. App apply
unchanged: 391 manager-core unit tests + the apply/prune/staleness/overlay
journeys all green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adversarial review of Phase 4-lite found two real gaps, both rooted in the
apply engine resolving script `id → name` from `current.scripts` (app-own)
only — so a route/trigger bound to an inherited GROUP script (whose id is not
app-own) couldn't be named:
* **Prune gap (reachable via pure declarative apply):** a trigger bound to an
inherited group script, once dropped from the manifest, never diffed to a
Delete (the diff couldn't resolve its identity once the bundle stopped
referencing the name), so `apply --prune` silently orphaned it.
* **Bound-plan false-negative:** `state_token` excluded such a trigger from
its fingerprint, so the StateMoved check missed a concurrent edit to that
binding class. (Routes were already safe — they hash the raw `script_id`.)
Fix: `resolve_current_target_names` resolves the names of group scripts the
app's CURRENT routes/triggers are bound to (by id, independent of the bundle),
and that map now feeds `compute_diff_with_names`, `state_token_with_names`, and
the prune trigger-identity map. App-owned bindings are unaffected (their names
are already in `current.scripts`). Also fixes a stale "in this app" conflict
message for group-owned scripts.
New journey `inherited_bound_trigger_is_pruned_when_dropped` proves prune now
removes an inherited-bound cron trigger. Full journey suite 105/105.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Mark §11.4 ✅ shipped with the live-resolution decision (no body
materialization / invalidation fan-out, mirroring Phase 3's config), the
shipped surface, and the deliberate Phase-4b deferrals (group modules + lexical
import resolver, invoke-by-id, live auto-rebinding). Note the sharp edge:
routes.script_id ON DELETE CASCADE means deleting a group script drops
descendant routes. Update the §5.1 materialization box and CLAUDE.md
(current-focus + the data-model invariant now covers group-owned scripts).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 4-lite C5. Two `pic` journeys:
* `group_script_is_inherited_with_cow_and_isolation` — a group endpoint
`shared` is invoked by name from an app under the group; the app's own
`shared` then shadows it (CoW); an app outside the group cannot reach it.
* `manifest_binds_route_to_inherited_group_script_idempotently` — a manifest
that declares no `greet` script binds a route to the inherited group
`greet`; plan shows a route create (no script create), apply succeeds, and
re-plan is a clean no-op.
Adds a `ScriptGuard` (deletes a script by id on drop) since a group-owned
script blocks its group's deletion (ON DELETE RESTRICT) — it must drop before
the GroupGuard.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 4-lite C4 — the headline declarative path. An app's manifest can now bind
a `[[routes]]` / `[[triggers]]` to a script it does NOT declare, resolving the
name to an inherited group-owned endpoint on the app's chain (nearest-owner
wins; an app's own script of the same name still shadows it — CoW).
* `resolve_inherited_targets(app_id, bundle)` resolves every route/trigger
target name that isn't an app-own manifest script to a group endpoint via
`get_by_name_inherited`, returning `name → script_id`. Run once before the
apply transaction (group scripts pre-exist, committed).
* `validate_bundle` takes the inherited endpoint names so "binds to unknown
script" / "is a module" checks pass for inherited targets.
* The apply transaction merges the inherited targets into `name_to_id`
(app-own keeps precedence), so route/trigger inserts bind to the group
script's id.
* `compute_diff_with_inherited` adds the inherited ids → names to the diff's
name map, so a route bound to a group script resolves its name and
re-apply is idempotent (without this it read as a perpetual rebind).
Live-validated: an app under group G with a manifest binding `GET /greet` to
the group's inherited `greet` plans as `route create → greet` (no script
create), applies (+1 route, +0 scripts), and re-plans as `noop` (idempotent).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 4-lite C3. A descendant app can now resolve and run a group-owned script
inherited down its ownership chain — the core of group-script inheritance.
Resolver (repo, reusing config_resolver's CHAIN_LEVELS_CTE):
* `get_by_name_inherited(app_id, name)` — walk app → ancestor groups
nearest-first, return the nearest script of that name (an app's own script
shadows an inherited group one: CoW).
* `is_invocable_by_app(script_id, app_id)` — EXISTS over the same chain; the
cross-app isolation predicate generalized to the hierarchy.
invoke(): `invoke("name", …)` resolves via `get_by_name_inherited`, so a script
can call a shared group endpoint by name. A group script always runs under the
*caller's* app context, never its owner.
Dispatch guards (the isolation backstops touched in C1) are now chain-aware via
a `Dispatcher::script_invocable` helper and the chain-aware
`validate_trigger_target`: app-owned scripts keep the in-memory fast path (no
query, behavior byte-identical to the pre-Phase-4 same-app guard); only a
group-owned candidate pays one chain query, and a non-member / query error
fails closed (dead-letter or reject — never run under another app's SdkCallCx).
The orchestrator HTTP route path needs no change: its per-app route trie
already scopes routes to one app, and it dispatches under the route's app
without reading script.app_id — a route bound to a group script just works.
Live-validated against the dev DB: an app under group G invoking the group's
`shared` returns its output; an app NOT under G cannot resolve it (isolation);
and after the app deploys its own `shared`, the same call returns the app's
version (CoW shadowing). Route/trigger binding of inherited scripts via the
declarative engine is C4.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 4-lite C2. Lets a group own scripts (templates inherited by descendant
apps), with the create/list/manage surface — but not yet the inherited
resolution (binding + runtime), which is C3.
Capabilities: add `GroupScriptsRead` (viewer+ on the group → script:read) and
`GroupScriptsWrite` (editor+ → script:write), mirroring the group-vars tier and
resolved through the same group-ancestor walk.
API:
* New `group_scripts_api`: `POST/GET /groups/{id}/scripts` — create a
group-owned endpoint script and list a group's own (non-inherited) rows.
Phase 4-lite is endpoint-only and self-contained: `kind=module` and any
`import` are rejected (group modules + the lexical resolver are Phase 4b).
Owner resolved first (slug-or-uuid); capability bound to the resolved id.
* The by-id `/scripts/{id}` get/update/delete/logs handlers are now
owner-polymorphic via a `script_cap` helper: app-owned scripts gate on
`App*` exactly as before; group-owned on `GroupScripts*`. This is what
makes `deploy --group` idempotent (update reuses the by-id PUT) and lets a
group script be deleted by id. (C1 had these fail closed for groups.)
Repo: `list_for_group(group_id)` (the group's own rows).
CLI: `pic scripts ls --group <g>`, `pic scripts deploy --group <g>` (create or
update by name; `--app`/`--group` are mutually exclusive, exactly one
required). `pic scripts delete <id>` already works for group scripts via the
owner-polymorphic by-id route.
Live-validated against the dev DB: create → update (v2 via the by-id PUT) →
list → delete, plus module rejection and the polymorphic row shape
(`app_id NULL`, `group_id` set). Group scripts still can't be routed/triggered
or invoked — that lands in C3.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 4-lite C1. Make script ownership polymorphic so a script can be owned
by a GROUP (a template inherited by descendant apps) instead of an app —
mirroring vars/secrets (0048/0049), but ON DELETE RESTRICT (code is not data).
Schema (0050): `scripts.group_id` (nullable FK→groups RESTRICT), `app_id` made
nullable, `scripts_owner_exactly_one` CHECK, and the per-app name index split
into two per-owner partial-unique indexes. Existing app-owned rows keep their
exact `(app_id, lower(name))` uniqueness.
Type: `Script.app_id` becomes `Option<AppId>`; add `Script.group_id` +
`ScriptOwner` / `is_owned_by_app()`. `NewScript` gains the same polymorphic
owner. The execution-context app (what a script runs *under*) is supplied by
the invoking route/trigger/caller, never read off the script — group scripts
have no single app.
Behavior is fully preserved for app-owned scripts (the only kind creatable
today): every isolation backstop and authz site now uses `is_owned_by_app`,
which is byte-identical for app owners and **fails closed** for group owners.
A group script therefore can't yet be run, route/trigger-bound, invoked, or
managed via the app-script API — those land in C2 (group-script creation) and
C3 (chain-membership resolution + binding). The `/execute/{id}` bypass 404s a
group script (no app context to run under).
Re-blesses expected_schema.txt; note the golden was last blessed at migration
0044, so this also captures the already-committed 0045–0049 schema.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
`apply_reconciles_app_vars` drives the full cycle through `pic` against a
real server: a manifest `[vars] region = "eu"` is applied (var created +
injected — a script `vars::get("region")` returns "eu"), the value is
changed and re-applied (Update, returns "us"), then the var is dropped and
`apply --prune` removes it (`vars::get` resolves to `()` / JSON null).
Exercises the Bundle.vars wire, diff_vars create/update/delete, the in-tx
writes, and the runtime resolver end to end.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Completes the vars round-trip: pull now fetches the app's OWN env-agnostic
vars (`vars_list` filtered to scope `*`, non-tombstone) and writes them
into the manifest `[vars]` block, alongside scripts/routes/secrets.
Inherited group vars stay out (pull exports own rows only, §4.6); a value
TOML can't represent (e.g. JSON null) is skipped with a warning. So
`pic pull` → edit → `pic apply` is now lossless for app config vars.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds a `[vars]` block to `picloud.toml` (key → TOML value), reconciled by
`pic plan`/`pic apply` alongside scripts/routes/triggers/secrets. Unlike
`[secrets]` (name-only), var values live inline since they aren't secret.
The overlay (`picloud.<env>.toml`) may carry `[vars]`; overlay keys win
per key (the env-specific value of an env-agnostic default).
`build_bundle` serializes the vars to JSON for the wire (TOML round-trips
via serde); `pic plan` shows a `var` row group and `pic apply` reports
`vars +c ~u -d`. The `PlanDto`/`ApplyReportDto` gain the matching fields.
`pic pull` carries an empty `[vars]` for now (export lands next). Adds a
round-trip + overlay-precedence unit test.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Extends the Phase-1 apply engine to manage app `vars` declaratively,
alongside scripts/routes/triggers/secrets. The `Bundle` gains a `vars`
map (key → JSON value; values are non-secret, so they live inline, unlike
secret names). `diff_vars` is value-sensitive: a changed value is an
Update, a live var the manifest dropped is a Delete (applied only under
`--prune` — vars are prunable config, unlike never-pruned secrets).
Writes go through `set_app_var_tx`/`delete_app_var_tx` inside the apply
transaction (mirroring `PostgresVarsRepo::set` for `VarOwner::App`, scope
`*`), so they commit atomically with the rest of the apply and roll back
together on failure. `CurrentState` loads the app's OWN scope-`*`,
non-tombstone vars (inherited group vars and tombstones are out of scope
for the manifest); `state_token` folds them in so the bound-plan check
catches an out-of-band `pic vars set` between plan and apply. Keys are
validated against the same kebab rule as the vars admin API, and the
apply handler now requires `AppVarsWrite` when vars are touched or
`--prune` is set.
Scope: app-owned vars at scope `*` (an app *is* an environment). Group
vars via manifest and tombstone-via-manifest wait for the nested-manifest
model. Unit tests cover the create/update/noop/delete diff and the
state-token value sensitivity.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds the net-new env-scoped `vars` table + the §3 resolution engine
(env pre-filter, proximity-first, per-key map merge, explicit tombstones),
group-owned environment-scoped secrets with owner-discriminated AAD
(secret:group:{group_id}:{name}, disjoint from the unchanged app AAD so
existing ciphertexts still decrypt), masked group-secret reads (app devs
see exists, never plaintext; only owning-group principals read values;
runtime injection bypasses the human gate), the vars:: SDK, and
pic vars / pic secrets --group / config --effective. Migrations 0048
(vars) and 0049 (group secrets reshape).
Verified before merge: fmt/clippy(-D warnings) clean; manager-core +
executor-core 523 unit tests pass (incl. AAD cross-owner-swap rejection
and the pure §3 resolver semantics); check-versioning OK (49 migrations);
all 101 CLI journeys pass against a live DB, including masked-read
(group_secret_value_is_masked_from_app_devs), runtime injection +
override, and var inheritance. Commit 79f8c9d also fixes the 6
long-standing stale logs/scripts/roles journey assertions, so the suite
is now fully green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The groups/project-tool work had no home in the blueprint's version
scheme, two "Phase N" numbering schemes overlapped, and CLAUDE.md's
"current focus" was stale (claimed v1.1.0 SDK foundation; we're at v1.1.9
with the SDK line complete). Reconcile all three:
* blueprint §12 Phase 5 (v1.2, already titled "Advanced Workflows &
Hierarchies") — split into a Hierarchies track (the groups + project
tool initiative, with §11 Phases 1–3 marked shipped) and a Workflows
track, with sequencing flagged as an open call. This gives the work an
explicit version home: the Hierarchies half of v1.2.
* design doc header — Status Draft → Active, "scheduled as the Hierarchies
track of v1.2", and an explicit warning that §11's local Phase 1–6
numbering is distinct from the blueprint product-phase numbering.
* design doc §11.1 — a post-Phase-3 re-sequencing review: resolve Phase 4
scripts LIVE (drop the fan-out-invalidation sub-project, per the Phase 3
result); consider a "Phase 5-lite" (declarative apply of vars/secrets +
app scripts) before the hard group-scripts work; and force the two
deferred decisions (trigger/route templates vs tenant cardinality;
multi-repo ownership vs a single-repo start).
* CLAUDE.md — refresh "current focus" to v1.2 Hierarchies, and correct the
now-broken "every v1.1+ table is app_id NOT NULL" invariant: the new
group-inheritable config tables (vars, secrets) use a polymorphic owner
(group_id XOR app_id), not app_id NOT NULL.
Doc-only; no code change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 3 (group-inherited config) is implemented, so fold the outcome back
into the design doc (per its own "before it drifts" note) — and flag the
one deliberate divergence from the plan.
§5.1 / §11.3 / §12 prescribed a *materialized* per-app effective view with
a generation counter and fan-out invalidation. We shipped **live,
resolve-on-read inheritance** instead: one recursive CTE per
`vars::get`/`secrets::get`/`config/effective`, no cache. The org tree is
small and there was no pre-existing config cache to fight, so this is
cheap and sidesteps §10's unsolved invalidation SLA.
Records, mirroring the Phase 1/2 status blocks:
* a "Status (Phase 3): ✅ shipped" block in §11.3 with the full surface
(0048/0049 schema incl. `apps.environment`, the §3 resolver, vars SDK +
CRUD, group-secret AAD + inherited read, the two secret gates, masked
`config/effective`, `--explain`) and the live-vs-materialized rationale;
* §5.1 runtime-model bullet annotated as the deferred (Phase-4 script
inheritance) design, not Phase-3 runtime;
* §10 "invalidation SLA" and "inherited-membership revocation lag" marked
moot/resolved — no cache means immediate propagation;
* §12 resolver contract + the header framing updated to live resolution.
Doc-only; no code change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Six journeys asserted against output formats that changed in earlier
commits and had been failing regardless of branch:
* `pic scripts deploy` prints a `name`/`version`/`action` KvBlock, not a
prose "Created X vN" line. The name-override, version-bump, and the
editor-can-deploy role check now parse the KvBlock fields (asserting the
exact version + created/updated action) via a small `kv_field` helper.
* `pic logs` gained a `source` column (now `created_at, source, status,
summary`); the success/error-status and summary-truncation checks now
index the status at col 2 and the summary at col 3.
No production code touched — the deploys/logs always succeeded; only the
assertions were stale. Full `--test cli --include-ignored` suite is now
green (101 passed, 0 failed).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
`list_meta` orders by `(name, environment_scope)` — a group secret name
can carry several env-scoped rows — but the cursor encoded only `name`
and paginated with `name > $cursor`. When a name's scopes straddled a
page boundary, the remaining scope rows were silently skipped from the
admin listing. Switch to a composite `(name, environment_scope)` keyset
(base64url of `name \x1f scope`) and a Postgres row-comparison predicate.
App secrets (single `*` scope per name) were unaffected; group secrets
with multi-scope names now page completely. Found in final branch review.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two end-to-end journeys via `pic` against a real server:
* `group_secret_is_injected_then_app_value_overrides` — a group-owned
secret is injected into a descendant app's script through `secrets::get`
(decrypted under the group AAD), then an app-owned secret of the same
name shadows it (decrypted under the app AAD). Drives the resolver + both
owner-AAD open paths against Postgres.
* `group_secret_value_is_masked_from_app_devs` — the §5.3 boundary: an app
dev (editor on the app, no group role) is denied the secret VALUE (403)
yet still sees it EXISTS, masked, in `config/effective` (status set,
owner group, no value); a group_admin reads the value. Proves an app
runs with config its own devs cannot read.
Also updates the existing app-secrets `ls` journey for the new `env`
column (group secrets are env-scoped).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Mirrors `pic vars` on the secrets surface: `pic secrets ls/set/rm` take an
`--app`/`--group` owner selector (exactly-one) with `--env` for group
secrets. Adds `pic secrets read --group <g> <name> [--env]` — the only
command that reveals a secret value, hitting the group-gated value
endpoint. `pic config --effective` now folds in the resolved vars section
(value + owner + scope) and an `--explain` provenance view, alongside the
existing masked-secrets cross-reference, via `GET /config/effective`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds the Phase-3 admin surface on top of the group-secrets storage:
* `secrets_api` gains group routes under `/groups/{id}/secrets`
(set/list/delete, env-scoped) gated `GroupSecretsWrite` (editor+), plus
the ONE plaintext endpoint `GET /groups/{id}/secrets/{name}/value` gated
`GroupSecretsRead` (group_admin only). That is the masked-secret
boundary: a descendant app's dev sees a group secret EXISTS and consumes
it at runtime via `secrets::get`, but only a reader at the OWNING group
gets the value. App secrets stay env-agnostic (a stray `env` is rejected).
The owner is resolved first, then the capability binds to the resolved
id — never a path param.
* `config_api`: `GET /apps/{id}/config/effective` (gated `AppVarsRead`)
returns the resolved view a dev would get — every inherited var with its
value + provenance, and every inherited secret MASKED (name/owner/scope,
never the value). Backed by a new `fetch_effective_secret_meta`
(DISTINCT-ON nearest-wins, same ordering as the per-name resolver).
* authz: `GroupSecretsWrite` moves from `app:admin` to `script:write`
scope so its API-key scope matches its editor role tier (closing the
latent scope/role mismatch the checkpoint review flagged); the value
read `GroupSecretsRead` stays at `app:admin`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Migration 0049 reshapes `secrets` to the same polymorphic-owner contract
as `vars` (0048): a secret is owned by an app XOR an ancestor group,
carries an `environment_scope`, and the old PK `(app_id, name)` becomes
two partial-unique indexes `(owner, environment_scope, name)`. Existing
rows backfill to `app_id` + scope `'*'`; the v1 AAD does NOT include the
scope, so every current ciphertext keeps decrypting byte-for-byte.
`SecretsRepo` is generalised to be owner+scope keyed (`SecretOwner` moves
down from `secrets_service` and is re-exported for path stability). The
SDK read path now goes through `SecretsRepo::resolve`, which reuses the
shared `CHAIN_LEVELS_CTE` to walk app→ancestor-group→root, env-filters,
and takes the nearest level (`@E` beating `*` within a level) — returning
the winning owner so the value is decrypted under the AAD it was sealed
with. Runtime injection stays anchored to `cx.app_id`: an app only ever
resolves its own and its ancestors' secrets.
All callers updated to owner+scope (`SecretOwner::App(_)`, scope `'*'`):
the app-secrets admin API, the SDK service, and the apply email-secret
path. The 21 secrets unit tests (incl. the app/group AAD-disjointness and
cross-row swap proofs) stay green; the chain-walk was live-verified
against Postgres (nearest-wins + env-filter). Admin API for group secrets
and the masked-read endpoint land next (Step E).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
§3 step 1 treats an environment scope as *eligibility*, not a merge tier:
within a single level a value scoped `@E` shadows the same level's `*`
fallback — it never layers on top of it. The resolver's map-run loop
collected every leading object row regardless of (depth, scope), so a
level holding both an `@E` map and a `*` map would deep-merge the two
(and report a bogus `*` layer in `merged_from`) rather than letting the
`@E` map win alone.
Dedup the sorted candidates by depth before the map run: each level is a
single owner (single-parent tree) with at most one `@E` and one `*` row
per key after env-filtering, and `@E` sorts first, so keeping the first
row per level yields the level's winner. Scalar/tombstone cases already
went through the boundary path and were unaffected; only same-level
map-vs-map mis-merged.
Adds two regression tests (same-level suppression; suppressed `*` stays
invisible to cross-level merge). Found in checkpoint review.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The crypto foundation for group-owned secrets (the §5.3 'single hardest
correctness detail'), done first and proven before the storage/resolution
layer.
- SecretOwner{App(AppId)|Group(GroupId)}; secret_aad/seal/open take the
owner. The app AAD is byte-identical to the pre-Phase-3
'secret:{app_id}:{name}', so every existing v1 row decrypts unchanged;
group secrets use a disjoint 'secret:group:{group_id}:{name}' namespace
(the 'group:' infix separates app/group AAD even for equal UUIDs).
- All callers (SDK get/set, secrets_api, apply email-secret read) wrapped
in SecretOwner::App — behavior identical for app secrets.
- New audit test aad_distinguishes_app_and_group_owner proves the two
namespaces don't collide (both directions, even reusing the UUID); the
existing cross-app/cross-name swap audit tests stay green.
16 secrets_service tests pass; clippy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Completes the vars half of Phase 3 end-to-end:
- vars_repo: VarOwner{Group|App} upsert/delete/list (owner-kind-specific
SQL; ON CONFLICT restates the partial-index predicate).
- vars_api: GET/PUT/DELETE under /apps/{id}/vars and /groups/{id}/vars,
resolve-then-require gated on App/GroupVars{Read,Write}, secrets-style
error mapping + key/env-scope validation.
- pic vars ls/set/rm (--group|--app, --env, --json, --tombstone).
- journey test: a group var is inherited by a descendant app's
vars::get(), and an app-level value overrides it (proximity) — green.
386 manager-core lib tests + the vars journey pass; clippy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Scripts can now read group-inherited config via vars::get(key) / vars::all().
- shared: VarsService trait (read-only get/all) + NoopVarsService; added as
the 14th field on the Services bundle.
- manager-core: VarsServiceImpl resolves the calling app's config via
config_resolver (derives app_id from cx.app_id; AppVarsRead-gated for
authed principals, script-as-gate for anon).
- executor-core: vars:: Rhai bridge (get/all), registered in the SDK.
- authz: AppVarsRead/Write, GroupVarsRead/Write, GroupSecretsRead/Write
capabilities (group caps resolve via the Phase-2 ancestor walk; the
GroupSecretsRead human-read gate is group_admin-only, distinct from an
app's runtime injection).
- wired VarsServiceImpl into the picloud binary; updated the executor-core
test Services::new call sites.
386 manager-core lib tests green; clippy clean.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 3 foundation (docs §3): env-filtered, proximity-first config
inheritance down the group tree.
- Migration 0048: `vars` (polymorphic group|app owner via two nullable FKs
+ CHECK exactly-one, env scope, JSONB value, explicit tombstone) +
`apps.environment` (the env marker the resolver filters on — 'an
environment is an app').
- config_resolver: a shared chain-walk CTE (mirrors effective_app_role) that
walks app → ancestor groups, env-filters in SQL, plus a pure Rust
resolution pass implementing the §3 semantics SQL can't — per-key
proximity-first, @E-over-* within a level, map deep-merge, tombstone
suppression, and provenance for --explain.
Verified: 8 unit tests (incl. the §3.2 proximity-beats-env-specificity call,
deep-merge, tombstone, boundary) + the candidate-fetch CTE against live
Postgres (env-filter drops a non-matching @production value; nearer level
shadows farther).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds the GitLab-style single-parent group tree above apps: migration
0047 (groups + group_members + apps.group_id NOT NULL/RESTRICT with
single-root backfill), tree repos with an ancestor-walk cycle guard
under a coarse structural advisory lock, slug-freeze and structure_version,
hierarchy-aware RBAC (effective role = MAX across app membership + every
ancestor group, resolved live so revocation is immediate), new
Group{Read,Write,Admin}/InstanceCreateGroup caps that bound API keys
cannot obtain, plus `pic groups` and a dashboard group tree/detail/members.
Verified before merge: fmt/clippy(-D warnings)/check clean; manager-core
378 unit tests pass (incl. hierarchy authz + group repos); dashboard
npm run check 0 errors; check-versioning OK (47 migrations sequential).
New CLI groups journeys pass against a live DB — cycle guard
(reparent-into-descendant rejected), delete=RESTRICT, and
inherited-group-admin deploy + live revoke. The 6 failing logs/scripts/roles
journeys are the same pre-existing format drift on main, not regressions.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
SvelteKit UI for Phase-2 groups, mirroring the apps/users patterns:
- api.ts: Group/GroupDetail/GroupMember types + an api.groups client
(list/get/create/update/reparent/delete + nested members CRUD); optional
group selector wired into app create.
- routes/groups: a collapsible tree overview (assembled from parent_id)
with a New-group form, and a detail page with breadcrumb, subgroups/apps
lists, a rename form (no slug field — slug is frozen), a reparent
control, a delete button that surfaces the 409 RESTRICT message, and a
Members tab reusing RoleChip/ConfirmModal/ActionMenu.
- +layout.svelte: a Groups nav entry beside Apps.
npm run check: 0 errors; npm run build: success.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds the `pic groups` command family over /api/v1/admin/groups:
ls/tree, create (--parent), show (path + subgroups + apps), rename
(name/description; slug frozen), reparent (--to), rm (--recursive,
leaf-first; never auto-deletes apps), and members add/set/rm/ls. Also
`pic apps create --group <slug>` to place an app under a group.
End-to-end journey tests (tests/groups.rs, DB-gated) cover tree CRUD,
delete=RESTRICT (409 on a non-empty group), reparent cycle rejection, and
the headline invariant: a group_admin on an ancestor group can deploy to
an app it is NOT a direct member of (inherited membership), and loses that
access immediately on revoke — all green against a live server.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Server-side foundation for Phase-2 groups (no group-owned resources yet):
Shared types:
- GroupId, Group; App gains group_id; AppRole::{precedence,max} for
folding the highest effective role across the membership chain.
Repos:
- group_repo: tree CRUD with reparent (ancestor-walk cycle guard under a
coarse instance-wide structural advisory lock; slug frozen; bumps
structure_version) and delete=RESTRICT (refuses non-empty groups).
- group_members_repo: per-(user, group) role grants, mirroring app_members.
Hierarchy-aware authz (§5.3):
- AuthzRepo gains effective_app_role / effective_group_role (default to
direct membership / none, so the ~18 existing test stubs are untouched);
the Postgres impl resolves each via one depth-bounded recursive CTE that
MAXes the app's own row with every ancestor group_members row.
- can(): the Member path now folds inherited group roles, so a group_admin
on any ancestor is implicitly app_admin beneath it. New Capability
variants InstanceCreateGroup / Group{Read,Write,Admin}; group caps carry
no app_id (bound API keys can't manage groups). 8 new unit tests.
Admin API:
- groups_api: group CRUD + reparent (admin at both source and destination
parent, §5.6) + per-group members, all capability-gated.
- apps: POST /apps takes an optional parent group (default root); app
responses carry group_id; my_role now reflects the effective role.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Phase 2 (blueprint §5): groups form a single-parent org tree ABOVE apps.
This migration adds the tree + membership tables and gives every app a
parent (§9 adoption):
- groups: id, parent_id (self-FK ON DELETE RESTRICT), slug (instance-
global UNIQUE, frozen at creation), name, description, structure_version
(bumped on structural mutation), owner_project (inert §7 seam).
- group_members: (group_id, user_id, role) with the SAME three role
literals as app_members so AppRole round-trips and the authz rank table
covers both.
- apps.group_id: nullable add → backfill every app under a seeded 'root'
group → promote to NOT NULL + FK RESTRICT.
No group-owned resources yet (scripts/secrets stay app-owned — Phase 3).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Adds the declarative `pic` project tool (init/pull/plan/apply/prune,
env-scoped overlays, config --effective), the three-state `enabled`
lifecycle on scripts/routes with dispatcher fire-time re-checks, the
trigger `name` column + backfill, and cross-app/disabled-execution
backstops on every async dispatch path. Design captured in
docs/design/groups-and-project-tool.md.
Verified before merge: cargo fmt/clippy(-D warnings)/check clean;
manager-core 370+ unit tests pass (incl. dispatcher enabled-gates and
cross-app isolation); all new CLI journey tests pass against a live DB.
The 6 failing logs/scripts/roles journey tests are pre-existing format
drift on main, not regressions from this branch.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Update §4.3: the fire-time `enabled` re-check is shipped and test-backed on
BOTH async arms (the unified outbox `!resolved.active` gate and the queue
arm's fresh-script nack), with the specific regression tests cited, plus the
same-app backstop now present on every async build path.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Incidental `cargo fmt --all` normalization of two pre-existing over-width
`.lock()` chains in DevEmailSink; no behavior change.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Four review fixes on the `pic` surface:
- `config --effective` gains `--env`: it now resolves through the same
overlay as `plan`/`apply`, so the masked report targets the app those
commands act on instead of silently reading the base slug's secrets.
- `pull` gains `--force` and refuses to overwrite an existing
`picloud.toml` (and colliding `scripts/*.rhai`) without it — fail-fast
before any network call or write, mirroring `init`.
- Overlays (`ManifestOverlay`/`OverlayApp`) get `deny_unknown_fields`: a
`[[scripts]]`/`[[routes]]`/`[[triggers]]` table or a typo'd key in an
overlay now errors loudly instead of being silently dropped. +unit test.
- `apply` 409 (StateMoved — the only 409 the endpoint emits) surfaces an
actionable hint (re-run `pic plan`, or `--force`) instead of a bare
`HTTP 409`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The interactive create path rejects a module whose name shadows a built-in
SDK namespace (`kv`, `secrets`, …) so `import "kv"` can't resolve to a user
module, but `pic apply`'s `validate_bundle` skipped the check — a parity gap
that let a manifest create what the dashboard forbids. Gate it on
`ScriptKind::Module` and share the same `RESERVED_MODULE_NAMES` const (now
`pub(crate)`); endpoints remain unrestricted.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
The `enabled` lifecycle's "a disabled script is not executable via ANY
path" guarantee leaked on the queue arm, and the outbox trigger arm lacked
the cross-app backstop its siblings carry.
- Queue arm: `dispatch_one_queue` bypasses the unified `dispatch_one`
fire-time gate, so its only `enabled` guard was the per-tick
`list_active_queue_consumers` snapshot — a TOCTOU window for a message
claimed in a tick where the script was still enabled. Re-check the
freshly-read `script.enabled` before executing and release the claim
(`nack`) when disabled; the message stays queued and resumes on
re-enable. The nack is load-bearing: `reclaim_visibility_timeouts` only
reclaims claims for enabled triggers, so without it the message would
sit claimed indefinitely.
- Trigger arm: `resolve_trigger` built the ExecRequest with
`app_id = row.app_id` while sourcing the body from `trigger.script_id`
with no same-app check — the guard the queue/http/invoke arms already
have. Add it so a hand-edited/restored row can't run one app's script
under another's SdkCallCx.
Both regression-locked by new unit tests (full mock harness, verified to
fail if the gate is removed):
- queue_enabled_gate::disabled_queue_consumer_releases_claim_without_executing
- outbox_enabled_gate::disabled_http_outbox_row_is_dropped_without_executing
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
