port: a withholding reason was false -- the hidden leaf is a visible expanding ring

authored/rendering.json justified not drawing build_12,15/pgloading_loop5 with
'leaf scale (0,0)'. That describes t=0 and t=30 and nothing after. The leaf holds
pgloading_ring, scale ramping 0 -> 250 -> 800 -> 1000 with alpha full at t=55 --
an expanding fading ring, visible at scale 140 alpha 143 at the port's own pose
instant near t=44. Withholding it declines to draw SOMETHING.

Still withheld, on the reason already in the file: no oracle capture for a
loading screen and verify-screen's reference draws no leaves, so the content is
unadjudicable. Behaviour unchanged at 59530 px.

The two entries in that list were written to different standards -- ptlogo_eff2
gets four paragraphs working through both readings, pgloading_loop5 got one false
line. The difference is that one was interesting and one was a loading screen.

Also verifies the measurement in the same paragraph: 'max went 155 -> 232 when
drawn' reproduces at 231, differing pixels 20498 -> 58313. The file's numbers
were sound and its reasoning was not, in adjacent sentences.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01N7FiFFFwbvG2uxdcEh8HyF
This commit is contained in:
Sylpheed port agent
2026-08-30 07:16:07 +00:00
parent 789e8ab15c
commit 678467549b
3 changed files with 92 additions and 4 deletions

View File

@@ -36,9 +36,27 @@
" parent scale gates the leaf it is a 0.95 s flash; if the leaf runs free it",
" spins for 16 s. Nothing on the disc chooses and title_jp has no oracle",
" capture.",
" `build_12,15/pgloading_loop5` -- leaf scale (0,0). A zero scale is one of",
" the three historical failures this corpus names, so it is exactly where a",
" guess is most expensive.",
" `build_12,15/pgloading_loop5` -- STILL NOT DRAWN, but the reason given here",
" was WRONG and is replaced. It read \"leaf scale (0,0). A zero scale is one of",
" the three historical failures this corpus names\" -- which describes t=0 and",
" t=30 and nothing after them.",
"",
" What the leaf actually holds, read out of the export: ONE element,",
" `pgloading_ring`, with a sprite, whose scale ramps 0 -> 250 -> 800 -> 1000",
" while its alpha rises to full at t=55 and falls to nothing by t=130. An",
" expanding, fading ring -- a loading pulse, not a degenerate record.",
"",
" 🔴 And it is VISIBLE at the instant this port poses. `build_12`'s settle",
" window is [40, 48], so the pose lands near t=44, where the ring interpolates",
" to scale 140 at alpha 143. So withholding it is not declining to draw",
" nothing; it is declining to draw something, and the old reason hid that.",
"",
" It stays withheld on the reason below, which is the one that always applied:",
" there is no way to adjudicate it here. The loading screens have no oracle",
" capture -- the RE agent records them as not reachable from the title path --",
" and `verify-screen` compares against a renderer that draws no leaves at all.",
" Drawing it would put unadjudicable content on a screen, which is the same",
" test `ptlogo_eff2` fails.",
"",
"AND THERE IS NO WAY TO ADJUDICATE EITHER HERE. `title_jp` has no oracle",
"capture, and `verify-screen` compares against `sylpheed-cli`, which does not",