The refutation used the wrong hash function. A record key is tag_hash of the
record's own name, not the pak-TOC name_hash which lowercases and uses a
different modulus:
tag_hash("Formation_4_Bird") = 0x22a5eeed <- exactly the record key
name_hash("Formation_4_Bird") = 0x6286edad <- the wrong hash, hence
the recorded "0 of 16"
Formation_4_Bird IS a record name in FormationSet_S02.tbl and every record in
that table keys by tag_hash of its name. Across all 28 UnitGroup_S<NN>.tbl the
same holds for field keys: 6960 of 6960 are tag_hash(field name), 0 are
name_hash. So FormationID resolves by a direct hash lookup and the roster
indirection is NOT required for it.
This is exactly the trap idxd-container.md warns about, and it cost this file
a spurious refutation. The original text is kept below the correction.
The squadron half of the claim still stands and is marked so: a squadron
record's key is not tag_hash of the squadron id either -- tag_hash("TCN001")
is 0x760cdeaa against keys running 0x659aff47 -- because the record's NAME is
not the squadron id. That roster indirection is real.
Also closes the file's standing "the key derivation stays open, a second hash
function is unidentified": that function is tag_hash, recovered since.
Found while checking a subagent's claim rather than taking it -- it reported
the hash correction, and verifying it turned up that the FormationID half was
a stronger result than reported.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
FormationSet_S<NN>.tbl records are slot lists -- 1 + 8*FrameCount fields,
exactly. Resolving every squadron's FormationID and comparing gives
sum(n) <= FrameCount holding 1159/1160 across all 28 stages, 0 unresolved, with
539 filling the formation exactly. The single violation is a debug leftover
(S20, AI_Test / MessageSet_test, Formation_1_only with n=2) and is recorded.
The old 'n is not the _NN suffix of FormationID' observation was right but drew
the wrong conclusion: the suffix IS FrameCount, so n=9 against _30 just means 9
units in 9 of 30 slots.
Also: FormationID does not hash into its table (0/16). FormationSet carries a
name roster record -- no FrameCount, fields are (tag, name, '') with the tags
being the record keys -- the same convention as Enumerate_Squadrons. Second
occurrence of 'keys are resolved by an in-table roster, not by hashing'.
Does not close the 387-vs-300 gap, and the key derivation stays open.
stage\UnitGroup_S<NN>.tbl is now fully readable. A squadron record is Count
member tuples -- (unit model, message set, n, identity/nameplate) -- followed by
five named fields: Count, SideID, AIID, FormationID, DisableInterval. The
property entries carry their own field names inline, so the tag hash never has
to be inverted.
Two independent self-checks validate it corpus-wide, 1160/1160 each across all
28 stage tables on the disc:
- the length identity len(fields) == Count * 4 + 5, which is what pins the
member-tuple width at 4 and the named-field count at 5;
- agreement with the file's own Enumerate_Squadrons roster, which maps record
key to squadron id independently of the per-record string offset.
Adds tools/re-capture/unitgroup.py (pure static, runs no emulator) with a
--all --check self-check mode, and commits the Stage 02 dump as evidence.
Corrections to the container layout written yesterday, all three wrong:
- the 20-byte "(tag, 0, 0, count, size) section header" does not exist. It
was the file's last 16-byte record followed by a plain npool word. The
corrected layout is uniform across all 28 files; the old one failed on 9.
- squadron ids do not use a separate string base. Every offset in the file is
relative to the one string pool. The earlier "109 of 111" score was an
artefact of the uniform 7-byte id stride and had silently shifted every
name by three entries, which is why 17 TC*-named squadrons came out as
SideID=ADAN. The roster record refuted it outright.
- the roster is not always the last record; 9 stages put it elsewhere, so it
is found by its missing Count.
Refuted and kept: the 4-byte record key is not the squadron id's name hash
(0 of 112).
Not settled: what the key encodes, the member tuple's third field n, and where
the arrival interval values live. DisableInterval is only a per-squadron flag
(Yes for 31 of 1160); the durations, triggers and arrival positions are not in
this file. Formation_*.tbl and EnumSquadron_Test.tbl are next.
