Measured first, over GP_MAIN_GAME_E.pak, comparing every named-field read the
six struct loaders performed against the record table: 4435 reads, 2872 agreed,
**966 returned None for a field that has a value**, **596 flattened a field that
several records carry**, 1 was wrong (a weapon whose TargetType is the empty
string read back as the neighbouring token "Skip"). The prior report of
4453/2887/974/591/1 is the same picture; the small differences are definitional
(I count a read as flattened only when the records disagree).
Every read now goes through IdxdObject::record, and the types say where a value
comes from:
* Weapon = the `Weapon` record (launcher) + the `Shell` record (projectile).
Both carry an ID and a Name and — with `ShellWake` — an `Interval`, which the
flat reader merged; they are separate fields now. Power/Velocity/ranges/
LifeTime are Shell fields, which is why 427 weapon reads used to miss.
* CraftUnit/Vessel = `Generic` (hull) + `Maneuver` (flight model) +
`StructureCount` (counts) + `Shield`, plus a new `hardpoints: Vec<Hardpoint>`
— one entry per Turret_/Bridge_/Thruster_/Hatch_/ShieldGenerator_ record, each
with its own HP. A flat HP could only ever be one of them.
* PlayerConfig = `Player`, plus `phases: Vec<PlayerPhase>` (SpaceSize/SupplyRange
are per Phase_N) and `score: ByDifficulty<ScoreRules>` (MainMissionBonus is per
Score_<difficulty>; the flat answer was the Easy one).
* Character faces come from the `Faces` record's field names (identical output to
the old token scrape, 0 of 68 objects differ — now by construction).
* Stage = `StageResource` + `phases: Vec<StagePhase>`, and the packages it names.
* The `fields: BTreeMap` on every struct became `records: RecordSet`, which keeps
the record boundary; `RecordSet::everywhere(field)` answers "which record".
The token-scraping loaders move too, and this is where the old reader was worst:
* Arsenal: options are the positional fields of the STANDARD_<slot> records. The
scrape returned 16 nose options of which 8 were field keys and pilot names, and
47 for arm3 of which 38 were junk, while missing Mine_B2A and No_Equipment.
Now 8/12/9/9, all real weapons.
* Squadron: one record per squadron, members are Count*4 positional slots
(unit, message set, n, pilot) — 1160 squadrons with ids and 2295 member tuples,
against 28 idless squadrons and 47 members before. Agrees exactly with the
independent Python decode in docs/re/structures/unit-group-table.md.
* DemoMessage: 11775 lines against 10263, every one with a speaker, a portrait,
a delivery mode and a voice token, from fixed positional slots.
* PilotRoster: assignments are the records the `UNITS` record names, so each one
now carries its unit id, its loadout and the player marker.
* UnitRoster: the roster is the field *names* of the single `EnumUnit` record.
* load_weapons selects on the records (Weapon + Shell) rather than on token[0],
whose first byte is often a stray pool byte ("#Weapon", "%Weapon"). Same 131
objects, no heuristic. GP_HANGAR_ARSENAL.pak holds none of them — the module
doc's claim that player weapons live there was wrong.
schema:: constants keep their names and values but are documented for what they
are: record 0's name hash (PLAYER = Difficulty_Easy, UNIT = Maneuver, VESSEL =
Bridge_000, MESSAGE = Message_000), not a schema id.
Two things the migration exposes and does not fix, flagged in the docs instead:
load_units' bucket is 43 Type=Craft + 46 Type=Vessel objects (new `unit_type`
field lets a caller separate them), and StructureCount.TurretCount is not the
number of Turret_* records (the player's craft says 4 and has 63).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
It is a throwaway measurement harness I wrote in this session ("TEMPORARY
measurement scratch — not for commit") that a concurrent commit picked up
along with its own files. It asserts nothing and duplicates work that is now
covered by tests/game_data_disc.rs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
to_xma_riffs now emits the leading headerless segment when it sits at a whole
number of XMA1 packets and carries a non-zero byte. VOICE_D_453 goes from a
0.14 s trailing fragment to a 45116-byte leading sub-wave that dominates it.
I withdrew this exact change earlier for two reasons. Both are now answered
rather than argued away:
* "It recovers no audio" -- it used the STEREO format. At two channels every
bank yields exactly 1792 bytes, one frame, whatever its size. Mono yields up
to 113x more.
* "It matches 1524 of 8021 RIFF-bearing entries" -- the byte-level reach is
still 1524, but the audible reach is not. Across the 84 movie-bound banks
the segment adds >1 s to exactly 7, the hokyu_*_H tankers on D_453/D_454 --
precisely the broken ones -- and <=0.25 s to 66 of the rest. The largest
non-resupply addition is S04A at +0.66 s on a 256 s movie.
The safety oracle is recorded with its limits: 8 of the 84 banks ALREADY
exceed their movie's duration before the change, by hundredths of a second,
so it cannot resolve differences at that scale. It establishes scoping, not
correctness. Callers clamp to the movie length regardless.
VOICE_D_451's all-zero leading region is skipped by the non-zero guard, so
the rule cannot prepend silence to a bank that does not need it. Pinned, as
is the packet arithmetic (n = 8, 1, 7, 22, 29) which has no tunable.
slb_disc, movie_subtitle_disc and movie_manifest_disc all still pass.
NOT verified by ear -- that needs a human.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The load-bearing error of the whole voice-bank thread, and it is mine. It
stood for three iterations across two write-ups that each called the result
proven.
I treated a subtitle cue as a timestamp that must fall INSIDE the voice clip,
and concluded a 0.07 s clip could not host a cue at 4.70 s. A cue is when the
line STARTS. The voice plays from the cue, so the clip only has to fit the
window between the cue and the end of the movie. Under that reading every
bank fits at plain 48 kHz:
bank samples @48kHz cue window
D_450 158967 3.31 4.00 5.30
D_451 76084 1.59 3.70 5.60
D_452 119562 2.49 0.00 8.34
D_453 108608 2.26 4.70 4.60
D_454 167828 3.50 0.00 9.50
2-3.5 s is also the right length for the lines. Nothing is missing, and the
17091-20563 Hz window from the previous commit is void with it -- its lower
bound came from the same misreading.
What survives, because it was measured rather than interpreted: the leading
region is XMA1 mono, the decode runs to the final frame, and cue values are
seconds.
Separately settled, and it is what exposed the error: each shared bank holds
ONE generic line. The 3-5 movies bound to a bank have IDENTICAL subtitle
text, 5 banks out of 5 -- "Rhino 3 has landed. Commencing resupply.",
"Resupply complete. You are cleared for take-off!", and so on.
That also explains the historical in-game rejection of hokyu_DS_s13A ->
VOICE_D_452 that started this whole thread. The line is generic, identical
for s02A/s07A/s08A/s13A. Someone expecting a stage-13-specific line would
hear the generic one and call it wrong -- while the binding is exactly right.
The disc said so; the subtitle text now says so independently.
Still open: whether the leading mono region is additional audio or an
alternate take, since the totals above add it to the RIFF sub-waves.
Artifact: examples/shared_bank_takes.rs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
Two things settled, one of them a correction of my own claim from the last
iteration.
The cue unit is verified rather than assumed. parse_timing computes mm*60+ss,
but only if the token really is mm:ss.cc, so I checked against an independent
oracle: the movies are on the disc and a cue must land inside its own movie.
66 English movies with subtitle tracks, 0 cues land after the movie ends.
Centiseconds would have overflowed essentially all 66. The seconds reading
stands and the verdicts built on it survive.
"The sample rate does not converge" does not. I reported implied rates of
39742 / 20563 / 23108 Hz as irreconcilable. They are not estimates of the
same quantity -- each is a ONE-SIDED BOUND. The audio must be at least as
long as the last cue, so samples/cue is an UPPER bound; it cannot outlast its
movie, so samples/movie is a LOWER bound. Intersecting:
bank samples cue movie lower Hz upper Hz
VOICE_D_450 158967 4.00 9.30 17091 39742
VOICE_D_451 76084 3.70 9.30 8180 20563
VOICE_D_453 108608 4.70 9.30 11677 23108
=> 17091-20563 Hz, non-empty. A single rate IS consistent.
I had been comparing them as competing point estimates, which is why they
looked contradictory.
What is still open, and stated as such: that window contains no standard XMA
rate. The lower bound assumes a whole bank plays inside one movie, and each of
these banks is bound to 3-5 movie slots -- so if a bank holds several takes
the lower bound is void, leaving rate <= 20563, which 22050 nearly meets.
Next step recorded: establish whether a shared bank is one line or several.
Artifact: examples/cue_unit_check.rs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
Retried the format probe with the fmt chunk built to synth_xma1_fmt's exact
byte layout, and with the bank's own RIFF sub-wave decoded through the same
pipe as a CONTROL so a broken harness cannot masquerade as a result.
The channel count is the whole story:
bank lead B channels=2 channels=1
VOICE_D_450 16384 1792 46756
VOICE_D_451 2048 1792 896 (all-zero region: control)
VOICE_D_452 14336 1792 30154
VOICE_D_453 45056 1792 203648
VOICE_D_454 59392 1792 294440
channels=2 yields EXACTLY 1792 bytes for every bank regardless of size -- one
frame, then it stops. That constant is the tell. At channels=1 the same data
yields up to 113x more, and the control sub-wave decodes to 13568, so the
pipe works.
Why the previous probe got 0 bytes everywhere is now named: I read
synth_xma1_fmt(2, 2, 48000)'s second argument as a STREAM COUNT when it is a
CHANNEL MASK, and built the WAVEFORMATEX around that misreading.
Also recorded as a refutation, because it was tempting: solving for the
sample rate as decoded-samples / last-subtitle-cue does NOT converge. D_453
implies 21665 Hz -- close enough to 22050 that I nearly wrote it down -- but
D_450 implies 5844 Hz. No single rate explains both, and the decodes are
visibly partial (samples per input byte ranges 2.10-4.96 where a clean decode
would be near-constant).
So the container is identified and the duration is not. Next step recorded:
find why FFmpeg stops early, likely the hardcoded packet/subframe fields.
Artifact: examples/slb_fmt_probe.rs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The corpus said 0.14 s is "far too short for the spoken line". That is a
judgement about audio, and audio judgements cannot be made in this container.
The subtitle tracks settle it without listening: each carries cue START
times, and a subtitle that appears at t seconds cannot sit inside a clip
shorter than t.
FFmpeg-measured (not estimated from a compression ratio -- the first version
of this example used an 8:1 guess, which is not good enough to hang a
conclusion on):
hokyu_LS_s02A D_450 cue 4.00 s audio 1.41 s MISSING
hokyu_LS_s09A D_451 cue 3.70 s audio 1.81 s MISSING
hokyu_LS_s02H D_453 cue 4.70 s audio 0.07 s MISSING
hokyu_DS_s13A D_452 cue 0.00 s audio 1.21 s no signal
hokyu_DS_s07H D_454 cue 0.00 s audio 0.21 s no signal
Three of five are decisive; the other two have their only cue at 0.0 s and
say nothing either way. So something is genuinely missing from these banks --
established independently of the leading-region work, and measured rather
than felt.
The fmt-variation probe I recorded as the next step is INCONCLUSIVE and is
written up as such: 36 combinations over VOICE_D_453's 22-packet leading
region all produced 0 PCM bytes, including ones that should be equivalent to
the crate's own synth_xma1_fmt, which does parse. So the probe tested my
hand-built fmt chunk, not the hypothesis, and it is NOT evidence that the
region is non-XMA. The retry should use the crate's helper.
Artifact: examples/voice_len_vs_subs.rs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The corpus recorded that some unit fields the disc leaves defaulted inherit
from a sibling: Size_Y from Size_X, FCSRange from RadarRange, DefencePoint
from AttackVesselPoint. Size_Y was marked the one to trust, on 9/9 support
across 7 independent ships, and it is restated in INDEX.md.
The premise is false. These fields are not defaulted -- they are on disc for
113-114 of 114 unit tables -- and Size_Y DIFFERS from Size_X in 90 of them.
The mechanism, cross-tabulating "legacy reader missed it" against "equal on
disc":
pair seen+differ seen+equal miss+differ miss+equal
Size_Y / Size_X 90 0 0 24
FCSRange / RadarRange 54 0 1 58
DefencePoint / AttackVesselPoint 51 0 1 61
seen+equal is 0 for all three: a value shared with a sibling is ALWAYS
invisible to the string-pool reader, because the pool stores each distinct
string once. And the reader almost never misses a value that differs. So
"the missing value equals the sibling's" was true BY CONSTRUCTION -- the rule
re-derived the very condition that made the field go missing. That is why the
support looked perfect: it could not fail on the cases it was fitted to.
The two miss+differ cells are its real wrong predictions, both named:
UN_e104_ADAN_Carrier DefencePoint is 0.2 (rule says 0.003), and
UN_e011_ADAN_Attacker_B_HF_Wayne FCSRange is 3000.0 (rule says 6000.0).
Retracted in unit-struct-runtime.md (original reasoning kept below the
correction), live-unit-definitions.md and INDEX.md. Pinned by a disc test
that asserts the seen+equal cells stay zero, so the mechanism itself is
guarded, not just the counts. Artifact: examples/sibling_rule_check.rs.
This one was found by my own check after the subagent assigned to it stalled.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The structure is exact. In all five resupply banks the first RIFF sits at
HEADERLESS_DATA_OFFSET + n*2048, where 1392 is a constant this crate already
had and 2048 is the XMA1 packet size: n = 8, 1, 7, 22, 29. No free parameter
to tune, and the raw bytes agree -- high entropy from offset 0, then a zero
run immediately before the RIFF. VOICE_D_451 is the control, its single
packet being all zeros.
So I made the obvious fix, emitting that region as a sub-wave, and then
withdrew it on two measurements:
* It does not recover audio. Coverage went 5.4% -> 89.9% for VOICE_D_453, but
the emitted stream decodes through FFmpeg to 1792 PCM bytes -- silence --
while the RIFF sub-waves from the same banks decode to 150-270 KB. Byte
coverage was the wrong success metric and it looked like progress.
* It is not narrow. The rule matches 1524 of the 8021 RIFF-bearing entries in
sound.pak, including RT* movie banks that decode correctly today. Landing
it would have risked a wide regression in order to not-fix five banks.
to_xma_riffs is back to its previous behaviour, verified by re-measuring:
coverage is 5.4% / 9.7% again. The refuted attempt is recorded in the code
beside the branch it would have changed, so the next person does not
re-derive the arithmetic and re-make the change.
XMA1_PACKET is kept as a named constant because the blast-radius scan uses
it. Artifacts: examples/voice_bank_shape.rs (structure), voice_bank_dump.rs
(sub-waves for decoding), slb_hybrid_scan.rs (the 1524 count).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
movie_manifest::parse now reads BASE_INFO's positional field keys (the game's
own cutscene ids, stage*100 + slot) and follows each to its record, instead of
scraping the string pool. The pool stores each distinct string once, so a
REPEAT reference produced no token and read as "no binding".
That single cause explains every wrong cell: 13 later references to
VOICE_D_450..454, two to SUBTITLE_hokyu_LS_s11A.tbl, and MS01A's share of
pwterop_s01a.prt. All 18 hokyu movies are bound, not five.
Counts, verified independently by me against the disc before recording:
104 cutscene SLOTS binding 101 distinct MOVIES; 99 slots / 96 movies with a
voice track, 99 / 96 with a subtitle, 22 / 22 with a telop. The docs' old
94 / 83 / 21 are exactly the counts of DISTINCT POOL STRINGS -- not wrong
measurements, measurements of the wrong thing. Three denominators were being
conflated; the new test pins all three.
Two assertions in movie_manifest_disc.rs were false and are corrected:
hokyu_DS_s13A binds VOICE_D_452 and resolves to eng\etc\VOICE_D_452.slb. The
in-game verdict that rejected that value tested an INFERENCE from a shared
demo id, on a decoder that discards 85-87% of banks in this class -- see
voice-bank-leading-region.md, committed earlier today.
The ~104 script ids are no longer open: they are literal positional keys,
each naming its record, and all 104 resolve. The old "counts differ by three,
positional pairing does not work" has a concrete cause -- three resupply
movies are bound by TWO slots each.
Also corrected: the naming convention has 3 subtitle exceptions (s24A/s27A
borrow s11A's track) and 18 voice exceptions, not one and five.
The legacy scraper is kept as a fallback for blobs with no record table, so
the synthetic unit fixtures still exercise it.
Artifacts: examples/movie_map_csv.rs regenerates the CSV, now slot-keyed
(104 rows; the movie-keyed version silently dropped one slot of each
duplicate). Disc tests green.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The record table gives a DIRECT binding hokyu_DS_s13A -> VOICE_D_452, where
the corpus records the movie as unbound and movie_manifest_disc.rs asserts
None, citing an in-game verdict that this exact value was "the wrong
recording". That is the only place on the disc where a runtime observation
disagrees with the record table, so it was worth settling.
First, shape: these banks are SHARED. Five slots bind VOICE_D_452, five bind
451, four 450, four 453, three 454 -- 21 hokyu slots over five banks, and the
movies repeat too. Generic resupply cutscenes, not per-stage recordings.
The recorded explanation for 453 decoding to 0.14 s and 454 to 0.43 s was
that the banks are "likely multi-subwave / not cleanly sliced". Refuted: the
count of RIFF magics EQUALS the number of sub-waves recovered in all five
banks, and the last data chunk ends exactly at EOF in four of them. Nothing
between or after sub-waves is being missed.
The real defect: slb::to_xma_riffs finds audio by searching for the RIFF
magic, and a large region PRECEDES it. 87% of VOICE_D_453 and 85% of
VOICE_D_454 sit in front of the first RIFF -- 21-27% zero over 256 distinct
byte values, i.e. content, not padding. VOICE_D_451 is the control: its
leading region is 100% zero, 1 distinct value, real padding.
So the in-game verdict listened to a decode that had discarded most of the
bank, for exactly this bank class. It is evidence about the decoder, not
about the mapping. Note also that what was rejected was a value INFERRED
from a shared demo id; the record table supplies the same value as a stored
field, and only the inference was ever tested.
This does NOT establish the binding is right -- it removes the only recorded
evidence against it. What the leading region actually holds is undecoded, and
confirming the binding needs a human listening.
Artifact: examples/voice_bank_shape.rs.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
With the record table decoded there is finally a ground truth to check the
old string-pool reader against. It infers `key -> value` from pool adjacency,
which is a consequence of how records are written, not a rule of the format.
Verified by hand against the disc, with an independent parser:
* `FCSRange` = 500000.0 — the module docs' own canonical example of a field
"left at its default" that "omits the value string".
* `ShieldRatio` = 1.0, where `tests/pak_idxd_disc.rs` asserted None with the
comment "a defaulted/omitted field must be None". That test encoded the
false belief; it now keeps the None as a deliberate characterisation of the
legacy reader, with the true value asserted beside it.
* `get_raw("Model")` on GP_HANGAR_ARSENAL returns the first record's model for
every record — silent corruption, not an absent value. New test pins four
records that disagree with it.
The cause is the flat API having no way to name a record: only 548 of 6325
objects have one. `HP` on the DeltaSaber answers 1000.0, the hull, while 63
Turret_* records each carry their own 100.0 (measured — a first draft said 34,
taken from a report rather than from the disc).
Disc-wide rates are recorded as single-source and labelled as such: get_raw
52% wrong, typed getters 38% miss, but 100% correct on single-record objects.
Also records a negative result: the 504 unnamed field keys were NOT recovered.
A 572464-string dictionary and 73191 variants gave 0/42. The key deltas do
prove the preimage ends with the two decimal digits.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The binary region in front of the string pool was the parser's oldest open
note ("Not yet decoded"). It is a uniform 16-byte record array sorted by
name hash, a field count, a 12-byte field array sorted by key, a pool size,
and the pool. The trailing `pool_size == file_len - pool_base` identity makes
the layout self-checking, which is what caught the first wrong version.
Verified over the WHOLE disc with zero failures: 7750/7750 IDXD objects,
190782/190782 records reproducing their stored tag_hash, 1271462/1271462
named fields reproducing their key. IXUD is the same container with
ixud_hash, UTF-16BE and every offset in chars — 1104/1104 objects,
628165/628165 fields, checked with an independent parser.
Field names are stored on disc, so no preimage search is needed: a field's
middle word points at its own name. Only 504 fields disc-wide are hash-keyed
with no name; the other 1485073 nameless fields are positional, keyed by a
literal integer (line slots, movie ids).
Two long-held beliefs are WITHDRAWN:
* The word at 0x08 is not a schema hash. It is record 0's name_hash — the
format has no type field at all, and an object's kind is known only from
the caller that loads it. It survived as "schema" because tables of one
kind share their lowest-hashed record name. Caught by a test asserting
every movie id names a real record: 1005 -> STAGE10_PHASE01 failed because
tag_hash("STAGE10_PHASE01") IS 0x067025B9, that table's supposed schema id.
* The field's middle word is not an always-0xFFFFFFFF flags word. It is
0xFFFFFFFF for 54% of fields, enough to look constant in a small sample;
the tell was that it is constant per key ACROSS records, which a per-record
flag cannot be but a per-name pointer must.
`schema_hash` keeps its name rather than churn 33 call sites, with corrected
docs. The first sweep globbed dat/** and missed hidden/DefTables.pak (1425
objects); the test now walks the whole disc root.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
Found the routines in the disassembly DB rather than guessing from data:
sub_82447DF0 IDXD tag hash (lbz+extsb, modulus 0x00FFFFDF, magic 0x2101)
sub_82447E70 IXUD tag hash (lhz, 64-bit, modulus 0xFFFFFF67 then 0x00FFFFDF)
Both transcribed instruction-for-instruction into Python and Rust.
IXUD SOLVED. It defeated every single-modulus search because it chains TWO
exact moduli -- the loop reduces mod 2^32-153 in 64-bit arithmetic and only the
result is folded mod 2^24-33. A polynomial mod M1 folded through M2 is not a
polynomial mod anything, which is exactly why the gcd test returned 1. Verified
independently: 86/86 record keys and 108,261/108,261 field tags in
GP_MAIN_GAME_E.pak, and NoRecord -> 0x1c6d9c96.
CORRECTION 1: tag_hash must SIGN-EXTEND each byte (extsb). My reconstruction
used unsigned bytes and matched all 1.27M disc names -- every one is ASCII --
while disagreeing on ~90% of random inputs with a byte >= 0x80 (verified:
18096/20000). The disc could never have caught this; only the disassembly did.
CORRECTION 2: name_hash's reduction is EXACT, not lossy. The module doc claimed
the missing conditional subtract made it something other than %. rlwinm r6,r6,
9,23,31 is just hi>>23, and with RECIP = floor(2^55/M)+1 that is Granlund-
Montgomery magic division -- 0 wrong at every quotient boundary across the full
32-bit domain. Retracted.
cargo test -p sylpheed-formats --lib hash: 10/10.
Closes the 4-byte record key. tag_hash is name_hash's shape -- byte-sum
checksum in the top byte over a 24-bit modular polynomial -- with two different
constants: modulus 0x00FFFFDF (2^24-33, prime) instead of 0x00FFF9D7, and no
lowercasing, so tags are case-sensitive. name_hash explains 0 of 8643.
Recovered from the tables rather than the executable: every inline field name
is a known (name -> tag) pair, and comparing names differing in one character
gives the per-position weights 1, 0x100, 0x10000, 0x21, 0x2100, ... -- a byte
leaving bit 24 re-enters as 33, i.e. reduction mod 2^24-33. Holds where it is
easy to get wrong (distance 8 and 9 carry correctly).
A record's key is the tag of its own name: FormationSet rosters 362/362,
UnitGroup rosters 281/281, S02 squadron names 111/111 -- so records can be
addressed by name without reading the roster first.
Implemented in Python (unitgroup.tag_hash) and Rust
(sylpheed_formats::hash::tag_hash) with 3 new unit tests carrying disc-derived
vectors; cargo test -p sylpheed-formats --lib hash is 8/8 green.
Not settled: the guest routine is unlocated, so this uses exact modular
arithmetic where the game may use a Barrett step without final fixup.
TextIndex in sylpheed-formats::localization already indexes per-phase objective
text under S<NN>_P<n>_Objective_<i>, with hints and lose conditions alongside.
Querying it settles what the wave work spent many iterations circling, and a
disc test now pins it.
Stage 02 phase 1 is "Shoot down all invading enemy fighters while watching out
for attacks on the ACROPOLIS", losing if the ACROPOLIS is sunk. Phase 2 is
"Protect the Admiral's ship the CALIBAN until it has entered the safe zone",
losing if the CALIBAN is sunk. Phase 3 is "Destroy the interstellar cruise
missiles headed for Schlos Base", matching phase 3's roster of exactly nine
ISCMissile and SUBOBJ_013.
That explains the phase advances and shows they are not all the same kind. Phase
1 is a kill-all-marked-fighters gate -- fighters, not the turrets every run
killed almost exclusively. Phase 2 is positional and ends when the CALIBAN
reaches a safe zone, so "what advances a phase" never had a single answer.
It also closes a loop to the first session. The hints say red mission markers
[OB] indicate your targets, so REMAINING OB -- the HUD counter hunted in the
earliest iterations and located at 0xbdb59668 -- is the count of remaining
marked objective targets, which is phase-1 progress itself. The old reframing
that the counter is not a roster was right, and this names what it is. It is
also the correct signal to watch for an advance: not deployed, which only
changes once the next phase deploys, but REMAINING OB reaching zero, which is
the cause.
Method lesson recorded because the reflex will recur: localization.rs has had
objectives, hints and lose_conditions for some time, and several iterations were
spent reconstructing the same information by hand from SUBObjective strings and
the guide script. The reconstruction was not wasted -- it produced the IXUD
UTF-16BE and language\ prefix findings independently -- but the corpus should
have been searched before the disc was, and grep -rl TextIndex crates/ would
have saved the detour.
Minor discrepancy noted, not investigated: ixud.rs documents the string pool as
UTF-16BE and localization.rs as UTF-16LE.
The 16.16 reading of +0x04 rested on twelve bundles at 30.0. They are not twelve
witnesses: they are TWO bundles - pghud_range_main_em/emeff and
pghud_range_nose_em/emeff, both dur 30 - repeated across six language PAKs. A
30-frame flash is equally consistent with 0.5 s at 60 and 1 s at 30, so the
observation that "30.0 bundles are shorter" says almost nothing.
Worse for the clean fixed-point reading: the four bundles at 0x3C0001 would be
60.0000152 fps, which nobody authors. They are py_ranking_jump/py_ranking_next
dialogs, all dur 60. So the better reading is <rate:16>.<flag:16> - a rate-like
number in the high half and a small low field that is 0 on 2843 bundles and 1 on
four, meaning unknown.
Also stated: nothing in this container can settle it by timing, because the
emulator runs on software Vulkan far from real time - a stopwatch would measure
lavapipe rather than the game.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The rate/duration reading of the bundle header came from the values alone, so it
was checked against something the file states independently: the keyframe `time`
fields in the placement region.
Over the 2313 bundles that have both, the largest keyframe time is <= +0x08 in
EVERY one, none exceeds it, and 444 reach it exactly. The refutation attempt is
in the same data: a large unrelated constant would bound every time too, but the
max_time/+0x08 ratio would then pile up near zero - instead it peaks at exactly
1.0 with 520 bundles. Asserted, including the shape of that histogram, so the
bound cannot later be waved through as vacuous.
Stated precisely because the units are a separate claim: what is proven is that
+0x08 is the animation length in the SAME UNIT as a keyframe's time. That the
unit is frames still rests on the values (30/60/120/1200) and on the 16.16
reading of +0x04, which stays amber - the only new evidence for it is that the
twelve 30.0 bundles cap at +0x08 = 30 while the 2843 60.0 ones reach 1440, and
twelve bundles is not a demonstration.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The backlog asked what makes a bundle a screen rather than a fragment, and the
obvious suspect was the 32-byte header. Swept over all 2859 composable bundles
with a real declaration table.
The answer to the question is NO, and it is asserted rather than argued: no bit
of the flags word at +0x10 labels a screen. The best any bit manages is bit 13 -
403 bundles, 179 of them carrying a full-screen element, a 44% hit rate against a
12.8% base - and the commonest bit is set on 91% of everything. Enrichment, not a
marker.
The sweep found more than it was asked for, though. The header is not dead space:
+0x18 is 1280 on 2829 bundles and +0x1c is 720 on 2823 - the design resolution at
bundle level, the same pair the parser already reads out of a .rat record, and
asserted here. And +0x04 takes only three values, 0x3C0000 on 2843 and 0x1E0000
on 12, which are exactly 60.0 and 30.0 in 16.16 fixed point, with +0x08 taking
30/1200/120/60 - a frame rate and a duration in frames would fit a format whose
records are keyframe lists. That reading is marked amber: it comes from the
values alone and is not verified against an animation.
Also recorded, since the file will not say: element counts are min 1, median 2,
p75 5, p95 23, max 56, and only 365 bundles carry a full-screen element. The
population is mostly fragments and the separation is shape.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
Two readings were on record and both were wrong in different directions: the
structure doc called it "normal state -> focused state" from a single example,
and the backlog called it "refuted as focus; unexplained otherwise".
Classified every link reachable from a declaration table: 1467 links, and ALL
1467 resolve to a RATC child of their own bundle, ALL are .rat -> .rat, none
dangle and none self-link. 1076 (73%) match the <stem>f focus pattern; the other
391 are chains between effect records - px_bunk_eff01 -> pjex_eff -> pjex_eff07,
pveff01 -> pjeff02 -> pjeff21 - which also explains why only 227 targets are
themselves declared elements: the middle of a chain is, the end is not.
So `opt ` is a record-to-record reference within the bundle, and focus is its
commonest use rather than its meaning.
Coverage is stated rather than glossed: the bundles hold 18718 raw `opt ` tags
against the 1467 classified, because opt_link reads the first tag of a DECLARED
element's record. Roughly 92% of occurrences sit deeper in the chains (or are
byte coincidences - the scan is unaligned) and are untested. The numbers are
asserted so the answer cannot drift back into an anecdote.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The backlog's cheapest open question about the 60-byte entry: kind is a flags
word (0x10 untextured primitive, 0x4 repeated instance, 0x3002 button record), so
a focus bit would be the obvious answer and the name-pairing in
mark_focused_states would be a convention standing in for a real field.
It is not. Over every screen build on the disc: 54 name-paired focused/base
pairs, all 54 with IDENTICAL kind (all 0x0), NO bit ever set on the focused entry
and clear on its base, and the only words of the entry that ever differ are +48
and +52 - the pivot. The two entries differ in where the sprite sits and in
nothing else.
The test asserts all four numbers rather than just printing them, so the negative
is pinned instead of decaying back into a suspicion. Also noted: these buttons
carry kind = 0x0, so the documented 0x3002 "button record" belongs to the .rat
records and not to the .t32 sprites a menu draws.
Closes the declaration table, not the question - the focused state could still be
marked in the .rat record, the RATC child stream, or only in the game's code.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01PMRJjbxLqZtsb5Vb7KunPE
The three orders the derived rule was built from all live in GP_TITLE.pak, so
they cannot confirm it - the rule was fitted to them. These two are from
GP_SAVE_LOAD.pak, read off the running game now that the Canary threading fix
makes the main menu dependable.
The 9-element slot-list header composites EXACTLY as the sort predicts, on all 6
instances of it, and nothing about this screen was fed into the rule:
measured 7 8 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
derived 7 8 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
including TWO tied groups (0xb102 x2 and 0xb210 x5) that both come out in
declaration order, and the unkeyed pfeff00.prm fade quad last.
The 13-element save/load frame differs in exactly the two open questions and no
new ones: two unkeyed pfbase.tbm backgrounds paint FIRST where the sort puts the
keyless last - the splash's palogo_eff0.prm behaviour in a different file type,
so implied_layer_key now covers it - and the 0xb100 group of four paints
10,11,8,12 where declaration order is 8,10,11,12.
That second point is a SECOND screen with a mis-ordered tie, which is what the
question needed, and it immediately kills a candidate: 10 and 11 are kind=0x2002
while 8 and 12 are 0x0000, so "descending kind then declaration index"
reproduces 10,11,8,12 exactly - and then fails both title groups, where every
element of 0x8083 is kind 0 and where 0x80a0 would predict 2,3,4,5,0,1,7 against
a measured 0,2,4,7,1,3,5. Seven candidates refuted now.
16 disc tests green.
With the layer key and the primitives' implied keys in place, the tie-break -
how the game orders elements sharing a key - is all that is left between the
derived order and ground truth. Three measured screens now constrain it.
On the menu and the splash every tied group comes out in declaration order,
which is what the stable sort already gives. The title is the only screen that
discriminates, and nothing predicts it: 0x8083 x5 paints eff1, eff2, eff5, eff3,
eff4, and 0x80a0 x7 paints logo1 x3, tm, logo2 x3.
Refuted: declaration order; RATC child order; first keyframe time (52, 56, 62,
58, 60 - the measured order is not sorted by them); resting keyframe time;
resting X or Y (938, 938, 64, 788, 447); and T8aD header words +00, +04, +0c and
+10, which are either identical within a group or unsorted.
Child order is worth its own line: a strict improvement over declaration order
(7 misplaced positions on the title instead of 9, and it recovers the logo
grouping) and exactly right on the other two screens. NOT adopted, because on the
only screen that can tell them apart it is still wrong.
Adds a test that measures what the residual costs instead of assuming it. Of the
3 disagreeing pairs of drawn elements across all three screens, all 3 have
overlapping bounding boxes and 2 share opaque pixels: ptlogo_back2eff5 against
eff3 (22568 px) and eff4 (32395 px). The third pair, ptlogo2 vs ptlogo_tm,
overlaps by two columns and shares NO opaque pixel - the wordmark is transparent
there. A bounding-box test called that a defect; reading the alpha says it is
not, which is why the test reads pixels. The set is pinned, so a change that
makes it worse fails.
15 disc tests green.
Two places checked for the key a .prm element sorts by, both empty:
* the declaration entry's four unread words are constant across every element
of all three measured screens (+28=0, +36=0xffffffff, +56=0, and +44 is a
button ordinal 1-5, 0xffffffff elsewhere);
* the bundle carries NO data for a primitive at all - the menu build declares
pteff00.prm, pteff02.prm and pteff05.t32 and has zero RATC children for any
of them, its 34 children being 21 T8aD sprites and 13 .rat records.
So the layer comes from the game code. But it is consistent, which is what makes
a per-name table a measurement rather than a fudge. Bracketing each unkeyed
element between the keys of its measured neighbours: pteff02.prm falls in
(0x8010, 0x8040) on BOTH screens it appears on, pteff00.prm is past the maximum
on both, and palogo_eff0.prm is below the minimum on the splash.
implied_layer_key records exactly those and nothing else; an unlisted primitive
keeps u32::MAX and still sorts last. With it, derived_paint_order produces the
same layer-key sequence as the order read off the running game on all three
measured screens - primitives included - and matches element-for-element on four
of the five bundle instances. The fifth is the title, differing only inside its
tied groups, which is a separate open question.
This does not make include_primitives safe by default: the 36 builds that come
out one colour are wiped by pzeff00.prm and pceff00.prm, never measured, hence
not in the table.
14 disc tests green.
Read off the running game with screen_children.py and identified by pivot
signature as GP_TITLE.pak ratc-index 8, the NEW GAME / LOAD GAME / TUTORIAL /
OPTIONS / EXTRAS screen:
paint order: 1 3 4 2 5 8 9 6 7 15 10 11 12 13 14 0
It is the first measured screen carrying TWO primitives, and they land in
different places, which is the point. pteff02.prm (the 25% dim) paints 4th,
beneath the whole UI; pteff00.prm (the transition fade, resting transparent)
paints last. Both match their positions on the title screen exactly. So a
primitive's place is per-element and stable by role - backdrop first, dim at
slot 4, fade last - and there are now three permutations to test a derivation
against rather than two.
Wired into measured_paint_order, keyed by element names so both language builds
get it. The English build composited with --primitives edge-correlates at 0.9591
at shift (0,0) against a framebuffer capture taken in the same session - a third
screen confirming paint order, resting pose, fade alpha and primitives at once,
against a capture this project had not seen before.
13 disc tests green.
fill_quad composites an untextured primitive as a solid rectangle of the
keyframes fade colour, pivot x 2 in size, placed and scaled exactly as a sprite
is. Behind ComposeOptions::include_primitives and screen render --primitives.
On the title screen, whose paint order is ground truth, it is measurably right:
mean luminance 76.30 -> 63.72 against the captures 64.58, i.e. from +18% to
-1.3%, and mean absolute difference 16.07 -> 13.08. The background was ~40% too
bright; pteff02.prm, a 25% black dim, was what was missing. The wordmark is not
dimmed by it because the measured order paints that quad at slot 4, beneath the
logo. Edge correlation moves 0.9538 -> 0.9480, which is not informative here: a
uniform dim scales gradients uniformly so a normalised edge score barely sees it.
OFF BY DEFAULT, and that is the finding. A primitive has no T8aD header, so no
layer key, and derived_paint_order sorts the keyless to the end. GP_DIALOGs
pzeff00.prm is a single keyframe of opaque black at full screen; painted last it
wipes the build. Of the 125 builds that draw a visible primitive, 36 come out
>99% one colour with the derived order.
No constant default works, because the two screens read off the running game
disagree: the splash paints its primitive FIRST (the black backdrop) while the
title paints one at slot 4 and another LAST (the fade-out). Declaration order
fails the title too. A disc test measures the damage rather than asserting the
feature works, so the number moves when the ordering is solved.
Also records a false alarm worth keeping: a first pass reported 36 GP_DIALOG
builds at "100% black", which was a crude near-black pixel threshold and not a
black screen - those dialogs are dimmed 50% and perfectly legible. The genuinely
wiped builds are a different set.
blit modulated by tint only, which is 0xffffffff on essentially every keyframe,
so the fade word was decoded, stored and then discarded. Applying it as an ARGB
modulate takes the title composite's edge correlation against the framebuffer
capture of the running game from 0.4597 to 0.9538, both at zero shift. The white
wordmark with its blue outline, the trademark, the copyright and the orange
exploding planet all appear -- the planet because a full-screen blue effect that
rests at alpha 0 had been painting over it at full opacity.
ARGB is measured: across a fade-in the high byte walks 0x00 -> 0x80 -> 0xc0 ->
0xe0 -> 0xff while the low three stay ffffff, and the low 24 bits are 0xffffff on
5276 of the disc's 5453 resting keyframes.
A modulate can only remove pixels, so the risk is a blank screen. Measured: no-op
on 4060 of 5200 sprite elements, partial on 453, hides 687 -- transient HUD
indicators that should not be lit at rest -- and NO build is left with nothing
visible. A disc test asserts that, and that the no-op share stays high, which
also guards the resting rule against drifting onto ramp frames.
Both changes are in one commit because the second is invisible without the first.
Applying fade erased the word PAUSE, which the running-game capture plainly
shows: pgptitle.rat has three runs of two identical keyframes -- pre-roll, hold,
exit -- and the 'later run wins' tie-break grabbed the exit. A group carries the
screen's entry animation AND its exit, so a run ending on the last keyframe is
now excluded unless it is the only one. The title correlation is unchanged.
Element::rest() picked the keyframe with the largest gap to the next keyframe's
time. That reads a keyframe as a value held until the next one; it is the start
of a ramp toward it. A long gap after keyframe k means the screen spends that
time arriving at k+1, so the settled pose is at the far end of the gap.
The title wordmark zooms in over five frames and holds at (184,193) at 100% from
t=251 to t=264. The old rule picked the frame before the long gap: (179,186) at
101%, still mid-zoom.
Measured against the framebuffer capture of the running title screen, which is a
1:1 crop so frame coordinates map directly (confirmed: the copyright line lands
on row 669 in the capture and in both composites). Edge-correlated over the
wordmark box:
plateau (landed) best 0.4597 at shift (0,0)
longest dwell (old) best 0.1511 at shift (+3,+8), 0.1268 at (0,0)
The old composite scores 3x lower and only peaks after being moved, by about the
(-5,-7) that picking kf4 instead of kf5 predicts.
It also fixes six title elements the old rule rested at alpha 0x00 where the
capture plainly shows them, and pteff00.prm - the full-screen fade quad painted
last - which rested at opaque black. That was the blocker on .prm compositing.
Adds tools/re-capture/align_to_capture.py, which is how this was scored, and
turns the .prm test that deliberately asserted the old defect into a guard on
the fix.
Not settled and now the next item: compose ignores the keyframe fade alpha
entirely (blit modulates by tint only), which is why choosing the wrong keyframe
was invisible until now.
369 .prm elements exist in the disc's screen builds and every composite is
missing them. Swept statically:
* none of the 369 has a RATC child of its own name — no payload, nothing to
draw, so .prm is a primitive and not a sprite;
* kind & 0x10 and a .prm name agree with ZERO exceptions in either direction
over all 965 builds, so the format marks primitives as a decoded field and a
port need not parse filenames;
* 361 of 369 are exactly 1280x720 at scale 100% in the corner, and their
keyframe 'fade' ARGB is overwhelmingly black at some alpha — these are the
fade-to-black, dim-behind-menu and flash layers, i.e. the PRMD dim-quad the
compositor's backdrop has been standing in for.
Refuted before believing: drawing them at Element::rest() is wrong. The title's
pteff00.prm is opaque -> transparent -> transparent -> opaque, a transition whose
resting pose is the transparent plateau; rest() picks by longest dwell and lands
on the opaque endpoint, which is painted LAST on that screen and would black out
the title. A test asserts that wrong answer deliberately so that fixing the
resting rule fails it and leads to the note.
No compositing change: the resting rule is not .prm-specific and has to be A/B'd
against the title framebuffer capture first.
The developer-logo splash declares its sprites directly and has no .rat layout
child, so is_build rejected it and no screen command could render it — despite
it being one of only two screens whose paint order has been read off the running
game, and the one where the layer key explains the whole permutation.
Adds ui_layout::is_composable (a declaration table plus at least one element
resolving to a T8aD the bundle carries) and an opt-in --all on screen
list/info/render. Measured on the disc: 2859 RATC bundles, 965 pass is_build,
2751 pass is_composable, and 0 pass is_build without passing it — a strict
superset. It is opt-in because the 1786 extra bundles are mostly two-element
fragments (a button and its glow), and because widening the default would
renumber --build for every pak, invalidating the build indices the corpus's
notes cite by number.
The splash now renders 6/7 elements, painting its glows first in the order
measured off the game; a disc test pins that order.
`compose` skips focused-state records by default, so whatever that flag matches
vanishes from every composite. It matched a trailing `f` in the name and nothing
else, which is not the convention — it is a letter.
Measured across the disc: 2458 elements match the suffix and only 54 of them
have the base element they would be the focused version of; all 54 are
`pgmenu_btnNNf.t32`. The other 2404, spread over 864 bundles, are `_eff` glow
layers whose names end in the same letter — `pb_name_eff.t32` alone accounts for
1122 of them, and `palogo_gamearts_eff.t32` is one the draw capture shows the
game painting, before its logo, with its own layer key.
Requiring the pair recovers 587 glows in the composable builds. GP_OPTIONS is
the plainest case: without `pbmwindow_eff.t32` the panel had no window at all,
just two floating brackets (captures/ui-layout/options-with{out,}-its-glow-layer.png).
Two other candidate rules were tried and refuted first. The `opt` link is not a
focus link: 221 elements are opt-targets, only 2 of them suffix-match, and the
targets include `pjnet_bg.rat` and `pv_loading_loop1.rat`. And the suffix alone,
as shown above, is unrelated to anything.
The layer-key order was adopted from two measured screens and then applied to
every build on the disc, so it owed a regression check against the screens the
corpus had already validated against the running game.
Rendered the tutorial PAUSE menu and the title main menu both ways and diffed:
3.8 % and 1.1 % of pixels differ, max delta 45/255 and 34/255, and the two
renders are indistinguishable in layout — the change is confined to blends where
translucent sprites overlap. No regression, but which order is more faithful on
those two screens is unsettled and recorded as such.
Adds a corpus-wide test asserting every composite's draw list is strictly
increasing in (layer key, declaration index), streaming one pak at a time so it
does not OOM alongside the other whole-disc tests. It reports the rule's reach:
341 of 965 builds are reordered, and it fails if that share collapses.
compose now sorts elements by the word at +0x08 of their sprite's T8aD header
instead of painting in declaration order, for every build except the two whose
measured order is hard-coded. That word is non-decreasing in the order the game
actually paints both measured screens, so every screen nobody has captured now
gets its layering from the file rather than from the declaration table, which is
provably not the paint order.
Verified with artifacts and both ways, not by a green build: the disc test
asserts the measured orders never invert the key and that the composite's key
sequence is sorted, and reading the word from +0x0c instead makes it fail; the
title composites identically; and GP_MISSION_SELECT — uncaptured — now composites
cleanly, committed as a capture.
Two things recorded rather than smoothed over: ties keep declaration order
because the game breaks them some other way that is not known, and the
developer-logo splash has no .rat child, so is_build rejects it and the
compositor never sees that bundle at all — its measured order is inert in
practice and screen render cannot draw it.
Checking the blast radius of the previous commit's `kind = 0x4` skip found 174
elements on the disc that are 0x4 with no non-0x4 element of the same sprite —
GP_READY_ROOM pak entry 75 is 56 elements and every one is 0x4, a list of real
icons a blanket skip would erase. So the rule is narrowed: skip an instance only
when its template is present, which is the case the title capture covers. The
title render is byte-identical before and after, so the narrowing changes nothing
the evidence covers.
And the claim that this "caught a regression" is WITHDRAWN, because measuring it
refuted it: none of those 174 elements is in a bundle `is_build` accepts, so none
of them ever reaches the compositor. The blanket skip would have been harmless in
practice. The narrow rule is a precaution, not a fix, and the comment says so.
The test that was going to assert the regression could not find such a build —
correctly, since none is composable. It is replaced by one that pins the fact
which makes the narrow rule safe: no composable build on the disc has a 0x4
element without its template, checked across 500+ builds. If that stops being
true it fails, instead of a screen quietly going empty.
The compositor painted in declaration order, which the draw capture proved wrong
— the title's background is declared ninth and paints first. The order the game
uses is its runtime child list, and no decoded field reproduces it, so rather
than leave the screen composited wrongly this lands the orders that HAVE been
read off the running game and falls back to declaration order everywhere else.
Two builds are covered: GP_TITLE's title build and the GAME ARTS / SETA / studio
anima splash. Keyed by element names, which identify a build across paks and
language variants.
Rendering it exposed a second defect, and the same capture settles it: the
kind = 0x4 elements are motion-trail ghosts, not resting content. The bundle
declares three instances of each wordmark; the capture shows exactly ONE quad at
each wordmark's position. Drawing them at their resting keyframe put three
oversized PROJECT SYLPHEED copies across the composite. They are now skipped.
Verified with an artifact, not a green build: the composite is committed
(captures/title-composited-measured-order.png) and now reads as the title screen
— background, planet, ship, wordmark, TM, copyright, correctly layered.
The test is disc-gated and was checked BOTH ways: it passes as landed, and
disabling the order table makes it fail. It reads one pak rather than every
build on the disc — the first version used the all-builds helper and got the
test process OOM-killed running alongside the other three.
`static_assembly_matches_runtime_capture` walks the capture's parts and looks
each up in ours, so an extra static placement was originally invisible to it —
that is how `e303_wep_01` sat here decoded 100x too large. `64d372c` closed that
with a set-of-names check; BACKLOG.md still says otherwise, and it is wrong.
One direction stayed open, though: a set cannot fail on a resource placed
*twice* when the capture lists it once. That is not hypothetical — a duplicated
instance is what a bad node walk emits, and the two legitimate duplicates here
(`e106_eng_01`, `e303_wep_01`) are why the test had to special-case counts at
all. So pin the whole multiset — 9 resources, 11 placements, against the
capture's 8 dedup'd parts — which subsumes both hand-written counts and fails on
an extra, a missing, or a duplicated placement.
Refuted before believing: perturbing the expected table (declaring
`e106_bdy_01` twice) fails with the real multiset on the left, so the assertion
runs against the disc rather than skipping for want of SYLPHEED_ISO.
The remaining `for want in &cap.parts` loop guards the table itself: editing it
cannot quietly drop a part the runtime actually draws.
The title screen needs an order that puts element 13 (`ptbase2.t32`, the
full-screen background) behind elements 0-5 (the wordmarks) — the capture shows
the wordmarks on top, so the declaration table is not it. Two other orderings
the bundle carries were the cheap candidates, and both are now dead:
* the **placement region** stores a keyframe group per element with an explicit
element index, so it could be a second ordering. It is not — it equals the
declaration order on every build on the disc. `UiBuild::placement_order`
exposes it and `placement_region_order_is_never_a_second_ordering` pins it, so
the refutation stays checkable instead of remembered.
* the **RATC child order** is the declaration order with the `.prm` elements
absent — strictly less information, and no place to put the background other
than where the table already puts it.
`screen info --geometry` prints both, plus each element's decoded sprite size
beside `pivot*2` and every keyframe's scale/position/time — the numbers a
placement hypothesis has to be tested against, and how the pivot/scale rule in
the previous commit was found.
`title_background_is_full_screen` pins that rule against the disc rather than a
synthetic sprite. `scaled_elements_are_a_small_and_mostly_undiscriminating_minority`
reports the scope honestly: 865 of 5 130 resting placements are scaled at all,
and only 213 of those could tell "about the pivot" from "about the sprite
centre" — which the capture did *not* settle, because `ptbase2`'s pivot is its
centre. It also counts how far `pivot*2` is from the decoded size disc-wide
(2 521 agree, 1 884 are off by more than 16 px), which demotes the "pivot is
exactly half the texture" result to a property of the tutorial bundle.
The compositor read a keyframe as `top-left = (X,Y)`, `size = decoded · scale`
and ignored the declared pivot. That is right at 100 %, which is every element
the format was ever checked against — the pause menu, the ARSENAL chip ruler —
and wrong for every element that is scaled.
Measured against a framebuffer capture of Canary on the title screen.
`GP_TITLE.pak` build 7 element 13 is `ptbase2.t32`: 640x360, pivot (320,180),
one keyframe at (320,180) with scale 200 %. From the corner that is a 1280x720
rect at 320..1600 x 180..900 — a quarter-screen slab with the top-left quadrant
bare. Anchored at the pivot it is (0,0)..(1280,720), and the capture shows the
background art reaching all four edges. Normalised cross-correlation of the
composite against the capture, searched over +-40 px, peaks at (0,0): 0.90 on
the planet limb, 0.72 on the lower-left ship.
`ptcopyright.t32` calibrates the other half: unscaled, 694x20 at (293,655), and
the capture's glyph run is x 295..986 / y 700..718 once the 45 px of window
chrome is taken off. So the keyframe really is the top-left at 1:1.
Disc-wide this moves 865 of 5 130 resting placements. The pause menu's own
`pgpeff01` glow stops hanging off the menu frame to the bottom-right and
centres on it.
`ComposeOptions::backdrop` comes with it: the default dim slate stands in for
the PRMD dim-quad behind an in-mission screen, but comparing against a
framebuffer needs the black the game actually composites over, so
`screen render --black` can ask for it.
Two independent lines landed a `.rat` reading and neither was the whole
picture, so this merges them into one module and fixes what the merge exposed.
ui_layout — the screen is the BUNDLE, not the set of .rat records
------------------------------------------------------------------
`feat/ui-layout-preview` parsed `.rat` records; the autopilot stack documented
the RATC header and probed it in `examples/screen_layout.rs` but never landed a
library module. The `.rat`-only reading structurally cannot see an element that
has no record -- the `eff*` frame corners, the `deli*` dividers, `msg` -- which
is exactly what the committed real-vs-rebuilt capture shows missing. Rebuilt
around the header:
* element declaration table at 0x20 (60-byte entries: name, parent index at
+32, kind flags, pivot) = the back-to-front draw list;
* the placement region after it = per-element keyframe groups.
Verified against the disc, each against a fact the docs state independently:
`pgpeff02a` -> parent 3 = `pgpeff02`; `pgp_ttrl_btn10` rests at (546,288); the
pause buttons sit at 268/337/407/478, the documented 70 px pitch; the Arsenal
carries X = -516. The tutorial PAUSE menu now composites 11/11 elements and
matches the real screen more closely than the earlier rebuild did.
Three defects found while validating, none of which any test would have caught:
* the keyframe block is 40 bytes with X/Y/time at +28/+32/+36 and an
alpha-ramping ARGB at +0 -- the fade, previously unread;
* a group's data stops 4 bytes short of its last block's time slot, so that
word is the NEXT group's element index. Reading it produced times like
1869640736 and silently corrupted the max-dwell pick. Last-frame time is
now `None`;
* the `.rat` sprite-name field is not 16 bytes. Capping it there truncated
`pgp_ttrl_title.t32` to `pgp_ttrl_title.t`, which resolved against nothing
and dropped 4 of 11 tutorial elements from the composite.
Max-dwell also needed a tie-break: on equal gaps take the LATER frame, or
`pgpmsg` reports the y=645 fly-through instead of the y=605 it settles at.
savegame -- a Rust port of tools/re-capture/savegame.py
------------------------------------------------------
GDHA container, zlib payload, chunk stream (GDAA / phase / GHAD 122 B / 16x20 B
SHAB / trailer). Every GHAD word carries its own confidence rather than the
block being presented as solved: 6 named, 2 recorded as REFUTED (+36, +56 were
tested as difficulty and as stage and are neither), 7 still unknown.
Tested against the three real saves committed under docs/re/captures -- no disc
and no emulator needed. The load-bearing assertion is the byte-identical
round-trip; the develop differential is asserted as a property (spending 4000 P
moves +24 and not its twin +28, steps the clear ratio, and moves exactly two
blob entries), and the header summary is checked to agree with the payload it
mirrors -- the trap that makes the Details panel a bad oracle.
CLI: `screen list|info|render` and `save info`, so both are checkable headlessly
in the same spirit as `mesh render`.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Two results from the running game, one positive and one a clean negative.
POSITIVE: with word A = 0x0001FFFE (stages 1-16) every entry Stage01..Stage16 is
selectable, where the control run had only Stage01 and the rest greyed. Stage16
reads "Lonely Blue Planet - NO RECORD". So any story stage can be launched from
the menu by poking one word, with no save editing at all -- a simpler lever than
the GHAD stage-field patch used until now.
NEGATIVE: with word B = 0x3F (challenge stages 24-29 marked cleared) the list
still saturates at Stage16 -- the cursor stops there and further presses do
nothing. That matches the disc: the debriefing config declares exactly
px_deb_stage01..16, so the list is capped by data, not by the mask. The
challenge missions are NOT reachable through MISSION SELECT, and word B does not
feed it.
Also mapped, without finding the caller: the GP_DIALOG registry (tables.pak #41)
gives DLG_GO_CHALLENGE_MISSION_MENU = 41 and DLG_CHALLENGE_MISSION_AVAILABLE = 42
(0-based, in config order). No raw immediate 41/39/37 appears anywhere in the
GamePart code region, so dialogs are raised through a computed index and the
entry point to GamePart 26 is still unknown. New probe: examples/screen_configs.rs
dumps any tables.pak screen config by substring.
Static only. Last commit left "REQUIREMENT is a bit index into a progress
bitfield" with the space unidentified. It is the achievement space, and both
halves are now readable off the disc and the executable.
- GamePart_Debriefing (0x8218CF38-0x82191B18) awards them: sub_8218F9A8 walks
the on-disc ACHIEVEMENTS_REQUIREMENTS list (tables.pak #16, schema 744c0519),
and for entry index n tests bit n, evaluates the entry when clear, and sets
the bit when satisfied. The list is literally ACHIEVEMENT01..ACHIEVEMENT24 --
24 entries, which is exactly where the challenge gate splits word A from
word B.
- The XEX carries the definitions: XACH at .pe 0x8FBCBC, 36-byte records
{id, name_id, unlocked_desc_id, locked_desc_id, image_id u32, gamerscore u16,
pad, flags u32, 16 zero bytes}, strings from one XSTR per language (English is
table #5). tools/xach_dump.py parses it. SELF-CHECK: the 24 gamerscores sum to
exactly 1000, the retail total -- a wrong stride does not land on a round 1000.
- The two sources agree on ORDER independently: the requirement types
ShootDownAircrafts 1000/10000, ShootDownShips 100, ShootDownWeight MegaTons,
GetAllWeapons and GetAllAchievements line up with ids 19-24 exactly as XACH
names them. So bit n <-> achievement n+1 is evidence, not inference. (Those
last two are requirement TYPES, not debug cheats, despite how they read.)
- Corollary: TimeAttack's REQUIREMENT 16 -- the one value that sits in direct
value-before-key adjacency, so it survives IDXD dedup -- is bit 16 =
achievement 17, "Solar System Defense Award", i.e. finish the story campaign.
The other five values (25-29) are >= 24 and so index word B, a second flag
space, plausibly a challenge-clear chain. Still 🟡.
REFUTED, from the last commit: the stores to +1956 in 0x822AF278 / sub_822C8748
are NOT this singleton. That object comes from 0x822CEB30, checks a +2652 flag
and stores string POINTERS at +1956/+2024 -- and a pointer ANDed with 1<<n is
meaningless as a gate. So nothing in the image writes this singleton's +1956
field-wise, and where the mask persists (save vs Xbox profile) is open. XEX
imports are by ordinal, so absent XamUser* strings are not evidence either way.
Static only. Bounding each GamePart's code block by its factory creator thunk
(id -> creator recovered for 22 of 24 registrations at 0x8280C000-0x8280F800)
puts GamePart_ChallengeMission at 0x82187E60-0x8218CF10. Resolving every string
that block references gives the screen's config schema, and the record itself is
on disc -- tables.pak schema 54a10697, one copy per language, English entry #64.
Six missions: TimeAttack (record Time), ScoreAttack (record Points) and
Extra01..Extra04, each with MISSION_ID / REQUIREMENT / REQUIREMENT_DESC /
THUMBNAIL / STAGE_DESC / NEW_STAGE and a NORMAL_BUTTON / GRAY_BUTTON pair -- so
the screen always lists all six and greys out what is not earned.
THE GATE (0x82189970-0x821899D8), read off the code:
REQUIREMENT absent -> available
REQUIREMENT == "Always" -> available
else n = atoi(REQUIREMENT)
n == 0 -> locked
n < 24 -> test bit n of the word at singleton+80
n >= 24 -> test bit (n-24) of the word at singleton+1956
The singleton is 0x821707C0 (lazy, global 0x828F48BC). So availability is one
bit in a progress bitfield and REQUIREMENT is a bit INDEX -- not a stage number,
score or difficulty.
Values per mission are 🟡: the pool's numeric tokens are 16/25/26/27/29 and
24/28 already appear earlier as font metrics, so they would be deduped -- which
fits 24..29 but IDXD dedup makes positional pairing unsound here, so it is
recorded as a hypothesis, not a table.
Negative: the requirement TEXT is not in GP_CHALLENGE.pak (TextIndex over it =
0 entries; its only prose is embedded font copyright). Its PATH is a per-language
branch the loader does not currently reproduce.
Next: three stores to +1956 sit in 0x822C7DD0 / 0x822C8748, the same region as
the save serializer 0x822C00E8 -- if the bits are save-backed, a hand-written
save unlocks all six challenge missions and the last 42 units become one run.
Static-only (no emulator, no pad input). Three findings, each with its own
evidence:
- The disc holds exactly 29 StageResource records in three families --
S01-S16 story, S18-S23 tutorial (all bg=Original), S24-S29 challenge, plus
Test. That is 16 + 6 + 6 + 1, matching weapon.tbl's stage01..16 /
tutorial01..06 / challenge01..06 key set exactly. S17 does not exist.
GP_CHALLENGE.pak has 0 IDXD objects -- it is the menu screen; challenge
missions reuse GP_MAIN_GAME_E.pak's records.
- The GamePart id table is at 0x820A1630 (29 ids). Indices are confirmed by
the image's own RegisterToFactory<N, class silph::GamePart_*> text, not by
position: GP_CHALLENGE = 26, GP_TUTORIAL = 25, GP_BUNK = 10.
- The stage loader selects its config section from a mission-KIND field at
object+144: 3 -> EXTRA, 5|6 -> CHALLENGE, else FILE (two independent sites,
0x82184df0 and 0x82185ed0; two more classify {3,5,6} as one group). The
constructor sets it to 0 and every write inside the class only clears it,
and no immediate 3/5/6 store to it exists image-wide -- so the kind is
supplied by the launching GamePart, never derived from the stage number.
That last point is a mechanism (unproven) for why patching the save's stage
field to 27 kills the load: the record is a challenge stage but the kind stays
FILE. Names an untried, zero-cost discriminator -- try stage 18-23.
Also flagged, not resolved: roster_target says S10 (a STORY stage) still
fields an unharvested unit, which contradicts the "story campaign complete"
claim by one unit.
examples/roster_target.rs ranks stages by how many roster units are still
unharvested. The EnumUnit_S<NN> tables are found by hashing candidate TOC paths
(hash::TOC_NAME_SCHEMES) — UnitRoster::stage can only infer a tag when the roster
carries a UN_S<NN>_ prop, which most do not.
It picked S09 (10 missing). Flying it: 26 -> 36 units, 3 345 -> 4 785 rows,
2 351 -> 3 439 defaulted-on-disc values. New: e102_Battleship, e104_Carrier,
e107_AAFrigate, e011_Attacker_B, e008_TurretPlus, be001_TerrafoamingUnit,
e001_Elan_GR{,_Violeta}, f102_LightCarrier_Inv, f106_Destroyer_Inv.
Also settled: the definition objects are mission-independent. Eleven units appear in
more than one snapshot and four are not byte-identical, but compared through the
layout ZERO mapped fields differ — the 12 differing slots are all unmapped (offsets
4/8/16/20 and 0x250/0x268/0x300-0x308/0x330-0x338: object header and sub-object
pointers). So a harvested value is the definition, not a per-mission tweak, and the
earlier UN_f201_TCAF_Tanker flag resolves the same way. Cross-checks over three
snapshots: 1 052 agree, 0 disagree.
Third angle field found the same way (Through_AngleMaximum = 60 degrees in radians),
so the degrees<->radians rule covers any name containing "Angle".
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NptfmpjdpNCKEez6d2xvA9
examples/why_missed.rs reports the furthest gate per undecoded resource. Disc-wide
that is 47 rows / 43 distinct names, and they are mostly not ship geometry:
30 e_rou_/_rou_ pose & proxy composites (24-vertex marker boxes, extent 0.010)
6 .DAT particle composites in ptc_pack
8 damage/LOD variants (e101_bdy_02_d, e901_wing_05_*_m, ...)
3 props/other (g005 extent 0.196, _rou_f001_wep_05, e_rou_e005)
By gate: extent 32, coverage 8, winding 7. The extent bucket is almost entirely the
pose-proxy boxes, and lowering that floor was measured and refuted earlier. The one
genuinely interesting residual is e901_wing_05_L/R at winding 0.587/0.570 against the
0.70 floor — the signature of a thin double-sided sheet, unproven without a capture
with the boss on screen (flying stage 16 puts the container in memory but the unit
never appeared).
So: 6 247 / 6 294 resources decode (99.25 %), and every real mesh drawn in three
captured missions decodes at the GPU's own offsets with index runs matching byte for
byte (93/93 and 128/128).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NptfmpjdpNCKEez6d2xvA9
With per-sub-mesh declarations enabled, n201_01 decoded as a 2-part fragment 4 bytes
off. Both starts validate for the pivot — 0x32BA718 at pad 2 (earlier in file order,
so first-match took it) and the capture-proven 0x32BA71C at pad 0 — so the pivot
alone cannot separate them; at the early one two of four sub-meshes fall out as
out-of-range.
anchor_grouped_meshes now builds each accepted candidate and keeps the one that
explains the most of the declared pool: it returns immediately when a candidate
explains all n sub-meshes, else keeps the best partial, so it can never decode less
than first-match did. n201_01 lands on all four capture-proven offsets
(0x32BA71C / 0x32BEFF4 / 0x32C416C / 0x32C536C) and its two sibling copies take their
own pools, so the twin collapse is gone.
XBG7_SUBMESH_DECLS is therefore on by default (=0 reverts):
resources that never decode 85 -> 47
resources decoding in no container 63 -> 30
degenerate index runs 1 -> 1 (unchanged)
cross-container minority decodes 96 -> 96 (unchanged)
captured index runs, stage-02 93/93 (unchanged)
captured index runs, stage-05 124/128 -> 128/128
The last line is the point: the buffers the capture could not name are the n201
family, and they now decode and match the GPU's indices byte for byte. Suite green
including twin_pairs_do_not_share_a_buffer, apart from the pre-existing
known-failing cross-container consistency test.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NptfmpjdpNCKEez6d2xvA9
desc_dump shows each index marker is followed by its OWN element triples: n201_01
declares strides 24, 24, 24 and 28 (the last sub-mesh has a fourth element), which
matches the runtime capture's stride=28 on that draw and the four distinct vertex
shaders. parse_vertex_decl read the first declaration for the whole pool.
all_vertex_decls reads one per marker; anchor_grouped_meshes uses each sub-mesh's
own stride for the pool walk, the pivot validation and the read. debug_grouped_report
follows the same setting so the diagnostic cannot blame the wrong gate — at n201_01's
capture-proven pool start it now reports "pad 0: ACCEPTED" instead of a NaN position.
With XBG7_SUBMESH_DECLS=1: resources that never decode 85 -> 47, resources decoding
in no container 63 -> 30, capture oracles unchanged (93/93 index runs, 42/42 index
counts), consistency unchanged at 96.
Off by default because selection has not caught up: the three n201_0x copies then
settle on one pool (twin_pairs_do_not_share_a_buffer fails), production still picks
a start 4 bytes before sub-mesh #1 rather than the proven one even though the proven
start validates and is unclaimed, and four newly decoded ptc_pack .dat composites
carry degenerate triangles. Format truth is settled; choosing among candidates is
the remaining work.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NptfmpjdpNCKEez6d2xvA9
capture_ib_truth now proposes an identity for each drawn buffer our decoder cannot
place, by matching (vertex, index) counts against declared-but-not-decoded
resources. That identified n201_01/_02/_03 in Stage_S02.xpr — three of the 63
resources that decode in no container — and the capture pins all four sub-meshes:
#0 vb 0x32BA71C ib 0x32B39FC 4464 idx 777 v stride 24
#1 vb 0x32BEFF4 ib 0x32B5CDC 4464 idx 869 v stride 24
#2 vb 0x32C416C ib 0x32B7FBC 576 idx 192 v stride 24
#3 vb 0x32C536C ib 0x32B843C 4464 idx 869 v stride 28 <- different
The layout matches our assumptions exactly (tight index packing, last buffer flush
against vb0 so pad 0, span 27936 == align4-summed markers, contiguous vertex
buffers, max index == verts-1 everywhere). The defect is that sub-mesh #3 has a
different stride AND its own vertex shader: anchor_grouped_meshes parses one
declaration per resource and applies its stride to every sub-mesh, so it reads #3
out of phase (372 non-finite position components of 2607), and since the pivot is
the largest index count with ties going to the last marker, the pivot IS that
sub-mesh — so the whole resource is declined.
Also adds examples/miss_targets.rs (which container to aim a capture at): 63
resources decode nowhere, 58 of them in exactly one container, clustering as
Stage_S16 21 (e901_wing_05_*), ptc_pack 12, Base 6, then per-stage n2xx groups.
Flying stage 16 did not draw the e901 wings — the container is resident but the
unit must also be on screen.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NptfmpjdpNCKEez6d2xvA9
